Monday, 1 October 2012

The BBC Smiley The Looking Glass War

I have listened to Le Carré The Looking Glass War, having previously seen the excellent film with Anthony Hopkins and Ralph Richardson. The radio play as the film which I have on DVD lacks the emotional punch of the Spy who came Back from the Cold. It is also the story of how the individual may be sacrificed for the national advantage and sometimes for the national good, although at other times just to save face.



It is also the story of those who having experienced the tensions and the challenges of wartrime or some other difficult, at times threatening experience, then find it difficult to impossible to cope with the everyday of normal times. In this instances it is those left from military intelligence during World War II who participated in dangerous and vital operations, risk their won lives or the lives of others asnd who are now restricted to making assessments and reporting information for others, the Circus, professional spying in Cold War peace time for the State.



When a former contact located in East Germany provides a photos of what appears to be Soviet rockets being moved into East Germany of a type similar to those which were attempted to be located in Cuba, instead of passing the information to the Circus the aging Director of the Department’s agency sees the opportunity to return to the old days of glory and arranges for the pilot of charter plane on its way to Scandinavia to fly over East Germany by mistake and take aerial photos of the alleged site area. Unfortunately his contact unable to get a taxi back to his hotel is knocked down and killed.



The decision is taken to send an office man to take responsibility for the body and personal effects in the hope of retrieving the film. The chosen individual is a young man who is already having difficulties with his wife because of his inability to share all the details of his work with her. She feels isolated at home caring for a young child and resentful oft his freedom which he husband appears to have, especially as he appears to enjoy and be satisfied by his work and role in life. It is not an uncommon situation and when he announces he is going off on a trip this only reinforces her feeling of being left out.



The trip is not success and no film is found although this only fuels the paranoia of the head of the department that their man was not killed in an accident and that the film was taken by the enemy. He therefore convinces the Minister that they should send in someone to check out the allegations but because this should be the responsibility of the Circus all that the Circus is official told is that the project is a training one just as the visit to Scandinavia had been, keeping their hand in so to speak in the event of being required to provide an operational service again. I am guessing that in reality the military retained their full operation role after the World War and if anything it remained as professional and more reliable than what happened to the British Circus, so named because of its location although apt given what was subsequently revealed.



The decision is taken to use someone who was sussful in the War but is long since retired with a liking for gin basd cocktails and women and for a training house to be established with the departmental the link which means he has to live in an and away from home, another divide which becomes unbridgeable.



Thus far there is close similarity between radio play and film although the operative is involved in a sexual adventure when he is contacted and if I rememebr correctly the location of the training house is on the coast and not Oxford as in the book,



The Circus with its Control are consulted and their passive help arranged with George Smiley the link pretending to know less than they do although they do not then know precisely what the Department is up to. When there is a request for the ltest radio communicatiosn device in the hope that direction finders can be avoided, Smiley explains that the technical boys will not pass out equipment over which they cannot maintain full control, but they let them have a war time radio one where the crystal has to be changed at regular intervals to enable some difficulties for the direction finders.



The operation is doomed of course and soon after crossing into East Germany the operative encounters a young border guard and instead of knocking him out kills him thus alerting the entire nation to be on the look out for the intruder. Worse is to come become because Smiley’s lot have analysed the photos and found them to be false. In the film the Operative goes to meet the contact who is also like the rest of Departmental team wanting to relive past times and be regarded as important and also well paid



The enemy becomes quickly aware of the travels of the agent via his use of the radio, forgetting to change the crystals and in order to mislead they arange for troops to enter the area so as to give the oeprative something to report and help them to identify his precise location. In the film he is given a lift and kills the driver adding to the deaths of the innocent of what is a wild goose chase. In both the novel and the film the agent meets up with a girl at bar in the town where the rocket (rockets) were reported as being seen.



While the net closes in the decision is taken back home to cut their loses so that when the operatuve is caught and put on a show trial it will be claimed this is a stunt and that a war time radio was found in possession illustrates the absurdity of the claims. This horrifies and angers the young man in the department having established a close relationship with the operative he cannot understand the betrayal, the abandonment, in the context of having managed a couple of days home between the training and preparing for the departure, his wife has announced she will not be there when he returns.



In the book the fate of the operative is uncertain as he hides out with the girl to make what is his final radio call adn in film there is a post script where some children playing in what is now a summer field by the roadside come across the roll of film which is opened and cast to the winds. There is also the implication in the film there was reality, albeit unknown to the contact, at the deployment of missiles.






 

 

 

 

Friday, 28 September 2012

The BBC Smiley The Spy who came in from the Cold

The Spy who Came in from the Cold
and which has Brian Cox in the role portrayed by Richard Burton in the film. It was as consequence of watching a TV showing of the Spy that I embarked on getting the DVD’s of the Smiley series to add some other Le Carré books and DVD’s I had already acquired after the
Disappointment of the film Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy. I have the film now ion DVD but have not viewed until doing with the sound turned off while I listened to the radio play which is provided on three DVDs. I then decided to also watch the film with the sound so as to establish the differences if any between the two as well as to reappraise the emotional and intellectual impact of both. Had I not such a long reading list before I would add the Spy such is the importance previously given to this work and reinforced by my experiences overnight.

The Spy who came in from the Cold provided audiences in the 1960 with reality of this work in the Cod War. There is an important discussion early on about the nature of the occupation in which unknowingly the main character Alec Leamas a wartime hero and until recently head of the Berlin Station is told by Control (head of service) that although while the soviets and others are aggressive in their approach to international relations, in the UK the policy is a defensive one, that the reality of the situation meant that the UK was required to adopt methods which at times were little different from those of our enemies. While as the book, and Radio play progresses it is evident that Leamas is told the full nature of the part he is to play or believes he has been told the part in full, we only know at the end that he has not and it is his reaction to this which stunned and affected cinema audience at the time and I assume those who had read or who went to read the book.

The Spy was a great success for Richard Burton as Alec Leamas and his co star Claire Bloom as the 23 year old communist who works for a small private library in which Burton is assigned by the Unemployment office after he leaves the service to go under cover in attempt to track down Hans Dieter Mundt who beat up Smiley in the first book to Call of the Dead Hans-Dieter Mundt and who turned out to be the assistant of his former friend and spy who dies when confronted by Smiley who then retires from the service.

Smiley is still retired but referred to at the commencement of the Spy and appears to play little part although there are confusing references and differences to his role between film and play which I would like resolved, for after all this book is part of the George Smiley series.

The first difference between film and radio play which I assume follows the book(s) more closely is that Leamas talks to the woman who we see drive over Checkpoint Charlie at the Berlin Wall when he is expecting his organising agent to arrive and who is the lover of the married woman who with her husband is able to cross over for stated reasons not remembered. It is conversation with her we learn that Mundt and Fiedler his number two of Soviet Security in East Germany have been systematically rounding up and killing all his agents. She says her lover will come over later and I found the radio play more intense and dramatic a description of his arrival part way across and being shot than in the film although both rank highly in terms of film openings. It is only later that we learn that his organiser in the East German network was a member of its Presidium and that he had provided us with the highest level of information about the governing Party and through membership of the security committee on security matters,

Leamas comes home and reports back and is asked if he feels burnt out or is willing to stay out in the cold longer and go after Mundt something he is only too willing to do given that Mundt was responsible for the deaths of all his network members in East Berlin, It is at this point Control admit that while the policy is not aggressive sometimes it is necessary to adopt methods like those of the enemy and therefore he has a plan to go after Mundt not through assassination but by discredit and making him look to be a British agent but letting the Soviets come to this conclusion through his deputy Fiedler, a Jew with Mundt was a former Nazi and both known to detest each other.

In the play we learn that the descent of Leamas officially out of the service is carefully planned and executed over a long period of time so that anyone checking would not be able to see that it was designed although whether because of the lapse of time the Soviets would see him as worthwhile approaching know to care about him was a gamble.

At the moment as I write and listen the evidence is that his placement in Library and meeting the young assistant member of the Communist Party CND supporter is not planned and indeed his handler repeatedly tells him not to get involved as he does himself realising that any intimate relationship makes him more vulnerable. It is when reminded of this after the young woman becomes his lover and after she cares for him when he become ill that the decision is taken for him to get himself arrested and sent to prison for three months.

There is a significant difference between the radio play and I assume the book text and the film. In the film Leamas is net by the girl who brings him a packet of sandwiches and says he will be staying her place when she his case. He will be there when she returns from work. There is no contact between him and the girl after he leaves prison.

The second difference is that in the film Michael Horden plays the Soviet contact posing as a representative for the After Care Charity the Link giving the impression of having official contact with the prison authorities and knowing he had refused to be helped by the Prison After Care association or speak to a prisoner. In the play he addresses Leamas by name and it is evident that he is contact on behalf of the Soviets. In both he plays a homosexual although while Horden’s manner is a give away this is not so in the play.

In the film Leamas is taken to lunch visits Control at Smiley’s home to report the contact Horden again for his £5 in case help and to meet his contact played by Robert Hardy as Carlton at a Soho girlie and drink club which is less seedy that reality and with a touch of the Windmill in style of presentation. When he accepts the offer of £15000 for his memoirs and £5000 retainer for availability for a further 12 months he insist on a visit to the girl for his suitcase refusing the demand for immediate availability and this also enables him to go to Smiley‘s House in Chelsea where George is there with control and confirms the plan and also demands that there is no contact between the service and the girl and that all records of her involvement should be removed. He tells he that he has to go away but plans to return and for them to be together.

In the radio play there is no contact between Leamas and the girl at all after he goes to prison although he had warned her that he had to do or finish something and that he would return to her. While he does go to a Soho club it is to meet Peters played in the film by Sam Wannamaker and by Michael Feast, the play who his Soviet contact to tell his story at a beach house somewhere in Holland.

When he visit the House in Chelsea he is told that Smiley is not there because he does not approve of the particular plan to get Mundt.

There is a long sequence which takes up the greater part of the second BBC CD in which the long term plots to get Mundt is first played out. His inquisitor appears to know everything there is about him but the one area of special interest is his role in thee banking section and the two field trips he made to Denmark and Sweden to take money paid into accounts there. He meets Fiedler number two to Mundt and realises that Fiedler is trying to prove that Mundt is a British spy.

The case is that after Mundtler beat up George Smiley and left him for dead in Call of Dead, he somehow managed to escape capture and was back in East Germany within a few days. The case is that during this time he was captured by the British and cut a deal. This is the weakest part of the ploy because turning someone into a traitor who is also professional trained, experienced and become and a senior operative take time as well as skill. Control has explained that the visits to Copenhagen and Stockholm( I passed through in train the first and stayed a few days in the latter) were part of the plan and where it emerges the money was paid and then withdrawn coinciding with visits to both cities by Mundt. Leamas is asked to sign letters to the banks seeking statements and one of these returns to show the amount was withdrawn when Mundt was there. This is the tipping proof for which Fiedler has searched over the previous three years that is from before Leamas agents were killed by Mundt. Leamas lays the role of a sceptic brilliantly Exclaiming that as head of he Berlin station eh would have known if Mundt or anyone had been a British agent above his man and team. Control had gone to Berlin to meet his agent to thank him and they had together for some 15 minutes, 10 in one version during which Leamas had not been present. It then becomes necessary for Leamas to move to East Germany, someone close to the Polish Border because his picture has been placed in he British press as a wanted man for breaking his parole, released after serving two months of his sentence. This was not happen in normal circumstances and still playing the traitor for money Leamas blames the Soviets as a means of forcing him behind the Iron curtain. What Leamas does not know is that Smiley has never left the service but author of the plan to get Mundt) or so it still seemed) and he had visited the girlfriend and offered her support on behalf of Leamas. She had then found that the lease on her flat was paid at a cost of £1000 by a charity which meant she no longer had to pay rent from her small salary.

Dramatically this part of the BBC serial ends as Mundt arrives and arrests Leamas beating him and asking his men to soften him up further before bringing to interrogation.

There is opportunity for Mundt to put his allegations that Leamas is part of a Smiley plot to discredit him before Fiedler arrives with authority for the release of and that a Tribunal is to be convened to hear his case against his boss. It is a persuasive case which eh outlines before calling Leamas as is witness backed up by a file of statements and the circumstantial evidence that Mundt is a traitor and should be executed. In the film the girl friend is approach and congratulated for her work as secretary of the small branch which as she has admitted to Leamas was because the member who proposed her fancied her and the branch only comprised seven members in total. She seeks. We hen see her gaining a holiday from her employer having been offered am exchange visit to East Berlin, The manager says she will not mention the travel is to East Germany to their employer. There is more conversation between her and Ashe from Party with no mention of the Link in the radio play but in both mediums she is not told about being called as a witness for Mundt until finding herself in the Tribunal and seeing Leamas also there. He is emotionally outraged that she has become involved and is warned more than one that further outburst will lead him to being removed and worse. The young woman is confused, afraid more for Leamas than herself and does not know what to say. Given the predicament he knows she is now in he decides to try and rescue her by admitting the truth that he is part of a plot to discredit Mundt. The case against Mundt is dropped and Fiedler is told there will now be an investigation into his conduct.

In the film all Fiedler can do is protest that this is the plan all along and that the traitor is to go unpunished. In the radio play there a calmer talk between Fiedler and Leamas because he has realised that Fiedler is right and that he has been set up not to catch Mundt who is working for the British but to discredit Fiedler because Mundt was turned by Control and Smiley and with their blessing he got rid the East German network in order top protect himself.

In both mediums Leamas is the first to find himself free by Mundt and in the play he has to plead for the girl to be released with him. In both they are given a car and instructions where to go and where they will meet and shown how to get over the wall. In both Leamas is told to go first and both are told not to stop or look back whatever happened and to remember that only some people have been told of the plan to get placements into the West and if there are any problems and delays they will find themselves being shot at by guards under instruction and without knowledge of their protected position.

This leads to one of the most moving powerful final scenes in the a motion picture as the girl is shot down on orders and then Leamas turns back down and is killed with her. In the play there is a conversation involving Control and Smiley over the decision of Leamas not to escape by leaving the girl when he had opportunity. It is Smiley I think who comments that this was his way of coming out of the Cold. Smiley is asked how long will Mundt be kept in place to which the reply is for as long as it serves the British purpose.


Monday, 24 September 2012

BBC George Smiley A Murder of Quality

On impulse I decided to listen to another of the BBC radio plays on the Le Carré books on George Smiley A Murder of Quality written I suspect when Le Carré was unsure which direction his character would take as it does not concern the world of spies and the London Circus but a who dun it in which the plot is fairly stock and at times difficult to take in a first hearing. Gorge had required and living alone when he is contacted by a war time circus colleague who edits a religious newspaper and who has received a letter from a woman fearing her husband was trying to kill her who is the wife of a master at a public school called Calne (the spelling is mine) and where the brother of another former colleague also teaches. His contact sounds rather like Connie of later books



In addition to Simon Russell Beale in the role of George Smiley it features Geoffrey Palmer as the master at a public school called Fielding whose brother George regarded as a friend.



He agrees and telephones Fielding only to find that the woman has been battered to death and that a local lunatic is suspected and has gone on the run. He then contact the police who pouts him touch with a local Inspector who he meets the following day to hand over the letter that had been received. The inspector as in the first book where he meet Inspector Mendal is more than willing to seek the advice of George and then his direct help as the public school is a closed community with little contact with the outside world.



The first problem is to determine motive but as the play progresses it emerges that the dead woman although religious was more than harmless gossip but someone who enjoyed hurting and controlling people, with a temper and as it emerges capable of blackmail where she realises that one of the masters at the school, George’s contact no less had been involved in a homosexual offence appearing before magistrates one of whom was her father although how she was able to make the connection is not disclosed. While the attention of the police does switch to the husband who is arrested when comes to see George whom is amazingly free with giving his address in addition to phone number to strangers.



The local woman described a lunatic is indeed funny peculiar and frightening to those who do not understand and mental illness and to some who do. She appears implicated where she has possession of costume jewellery belonging to the deceased and a coat which the woman had collected for a charity proving clothing to Hungarian refugees, a cause which the white was closely associated and sent regular parcels of those she had collected. She is not involved.



The man responsible for the death her is in fact Fielding. He was brought back to the school at the end of the end of World War II by the head on the basis of being temporary without a contract and this had remained the position which meant he would not receive a pension. The woman and tormented him and he had planned to get rid of her and implicate the mad woman unaware that she written the letter about her husband.



He was also responsible for the death of senior school boy academically struggling but a cellist with promise. He had looked into a music case and seen clothing which the murderer and used had used and then sent to the Refugee Committee in the hope.



There was some philosophy about the relatively of truth and the way UK society was changing from an era when gentlemen had worn evening dress and ladies special dresses and social behaviour was clearly defined and the subject for comment if individuals failed to conform or appreciate standards. The more I have reflected on the play the more I find it is of no consequence as I suspect the book. The only interest is the involvement of George as an interlude when it appears he too little to do other than reflect on his past life and the failed marriage.



 

 

 

To contact and find that the woman was battered to death after having a meal with her husband with Fielding. Through a contact he is put in contact with an Inspector Rigby appointed to investigate the case. A senior officer at the station attended the school and is interested and there are various oddness, including that although she said she had not contact someone at her local church she mentioned her fears but not more two weeks before she had written to the journal edited by Georges former friend.



He takes the letter to the Inspector and agrees to give advice because the school is a closed community to the local community. Who hated this woman to kill her? He muses to his former colleague



 

Saturday, 22 September 2012

The BBC Smiley Call of the Dead

The greater part of a year has passed since immersing myself in the world of John Le Carré and the opportunity to acquire the BBC broadcast plays of all the George Smiley novels as plays has provided the opportunity to engage again and yesterday I experienced the two disk 90 minute Call for the Dead and which I had previously appreciated as the 1966 film the Deadly Affair with James Mason as Smiley, Harriet Anderson as his ex wife, Simon Signoret at the wife the allegedly Foreign Office suicide Samuel Fennan and Maximillan Schell as his former spy and friend Dieter Frey. Given such an outstanding cast which also included Lynn Redgrave, Roy Kinnear and Harry Andrews as Mendal it was difficult to imagine that the BBC production could match the film where I have the 2006 produced DVD and believe I saw the original in Theatre as well as subsequently on TV. It is good especially the performance of Eleanor Bron as Mrs Fennan and Kenneth Graham as Inspector Mendal. No one can compare with the Alec Guinness interpretation of George Smiley but Simon Russell Beale does as good job as does Harry Goodman as Dieter Frey.

The story was therefore familiar rather like a classical music symphony such as the New World or the Beethoven Choral but enjoyable for a Friday night nevertheless reminding of Radio days long long ago.

George is asked to interview Fennan following receipt by his masters of a letter denouncing the civil servant as a spy. They walk in St James Park and George is impressed with the man who he likes and has no reservations about dismissing the letter without further investigation. The man is then reported to have committed suicide and his wife claims that the interview with George was the cause. George is under fire from his masters, (as usual) and when he visits the widow he takes a phone call, expecting one for himself and this sets the trail which leads to uncovering what really happened as well as to his own past as a field agent in post war and wartime Germany and the problems he had with marrying a woman who in the days of the forties to sixties would be described as free and then liberated as well as a minor aristocrat and who had the social class background that George lacked.

He enlists the help of local police man Inspector Mendal due to retire and thus commences the start of their relationship when he turns to the Inspector for refuge when an attempt is made on his life.

The story? Well Fennan was as George believed innocent and had in fact sent the letter provoking the investigation himself because he suspected that his wife was taking copies of his papers and passing them to someone. I am not sure if he tied this in with her regular visit to the local theatre company where she always sat in the same seat bringing a violin case with her and sitting with a gentleman who also occupied the same seat.

It was when George made the mistake of going for the walk that he was spotted by a former agent of his that the decision was taken for Fennan to die and for the attempt on life of George. It is the early morning alarm phone call that triggers the uncovering because Mendal establishes that it was made by the husband and not the wife as she claimed because she found it difficult to sleep and lost track of time as a consequence.

In the film we learn that Dieter was one of the men with whom his wife had an affair when he came to the UK after the War and it was one of his men Munk who had been the regular contact with the wife recruited after her experiences with the Nazi’s and who had killed her husband when they realised what was happening. Dieter had established a trading company in London as a cover for his operation. In the BBC Play I thought the closeness of the relationship between Smiley and Dieter was brought out more strongly as well as their mutual respect as the best of the best at their black art. It also brilliantly expresses the anguish felt by both men as Dieter presses Smiley to walk away than be killed and Smiley’s sense of loss and failure when it is Dieter than dies. His wife is an image in his mind throughout until the end with flashbacks in the film and as someone to talk to. A living conscience as well as memory, in his single loneliness in the radio play. In both as I assume the original book text, she contacts him saying her latest fling has not worked out and wants him back and he goes to collect her, as well as brining his career as a spook to an end and along with Mendal going to retirement of a kind. I almost forgot that he sets up a trap for the wife and Dieter at a production of a Shakespeare play in the West End during which they realise the position and the wife is killed within sight of the audience and the players.

Friday, 12 February 2010

Francis Durbridge and Paul Temple, A bus ride via Washington to Chester Le Street for cricket

A leisurely and practical morning where I worked until ten before coffee and toast and attended to a number of household chores before turning on the radio before noon to discover the serialization of a Paul Temple mystery.

Paul Temple was an amateur sleuth created my Francis Durbridge 1912- 1998. The books fact followed the radio series creation which commenced in 1938 and continued until the later 1960's and were then recreated commencing in 2006. My memory is of the post war series with Kim Peacock playing the lead, 1946 to 1953 and I may have also listened to some of those with Peter Coke until I left school and who was alive aged 93 in 2006 when he was interviewed about his involvement with the programme. Marjorie Westbury played the wife of Paul Temple Steve.

I was immediately taken back to those days by the programme signature tune which has remained the Coronation Scot, a musical train journey written by Vivian Ellis. In a world where everything appeared to have changed within my lifetime it is was splendid to discover something that had not.

I only heard about half of this episode of Paul Temple and the Madison Mystery, one of eight parts first heard with Kim Peacock in 1949 and then remade with Peter Coke in 1955, and commenced again on 16th May 2008. Among those appearing in the 1949 and 1955 versions were Andrew Faulds who became a Member of Parliament and Richard Waring, then an actor who became an established sitcom writer. It is evident that this a very different version from the original published story.

There were four made for the cinema movies and in 1964 the BBC commenced 64 television episodes with Francis Matthews and Ros Drinkwater. The radio series was also an even bigger hit in Germany where 12 novels were serialised in the German language with actors of national renown and are available as CD audio books to this day. The British Television series was made in collaboration with German TV. The latest radio series commenced with using vintage microphones and vintage sound effects. It was not the programme which affected plans for the rest of the planned day as I received a small package through the post which did, together with the ten black printer cartridges but not the radio controlled model cars.

I will have to make a list of things sent for an outstanding. But the small package, You must now sing the tune of the Coronation Scot to get the flavour of a serial that always ended with a question or a broad hint of what was to come, but then had to wait a whole week before the next part.

The success of Durham Cricket Club in reaching the quarter final stage of the Friends Provident Trophy 1 day 50 over competition prompted me to take out membership again as I discovered I could also buy tickets for the 20 20 series at half price. Although I missed the five free home ties and two four day games involving my boyhood team Surrey and Yorkshire, the nearest in cricket to a derby match, the £90 membership remained of great value for money with six up to four day games and for 4 40 40 games making a total of 28 days.
Whereas the pressure is on in to make reduction for elders as well as children and students, in cricket the need to improve the financial position of players, to encourage schools and youngsters to take up the game means that without membership there are no longer concessions for individual games. However in order to gain immediate concessions and ensure that I gained a seat in an area of the ground behind the bowlers arm a visit to the ground before 5pm Monday was required unless I was certain he post would arrived beforehand, The cost of the entrance fees is about half the cost of attending a cricket match because of petrol costs and car parking charges and a tendency to buy refreshments as well as score card programmes. There is a tradition among avid cricket fans to keep a record every ball and run scored, the details of when each wick fell and the bowling figures for each innings as well as various highlight figures such as rum and bowling rates, highest and lowest scores and such like and these are published in the media and collated annual in the cricketers annual bible Wisden's a monster book where collector will pay a fortune to own a complete set. The present price is £40 but as a club member there is a significant discount, presently £12, and which reminds that I must also collect my free copy of the Durham year book which normally costs £7.50. I have never been into Wisden, but I did follow the game more close at one point winning £250 or it may have been £500 in a Newspaper competition for picking the best composite team over a season and where I achieve a minor prize and overall highly placed with the certificate somewhere. This is along introduction to mentioning the decision to use my all England bus pass for the first time travelling outside the Tyne Wear area.

More Coronation Scot music while I make coffee and toast and which was good. Now to part three.
I knew that there were two ways of reaching the cricket ground from my home. I could take a bus from South Shields to Sunderland where there was a choice of three buses each taking a different route but all going along part of the coast road and from the Sunderland Interchange there were two buses which stopped at the Riverside Ground. I had also recently investigated that there was one bus from South Shields which went to the Bolden Asda and Cineworld Cinema, the to Washington, yes Washington the ancestral home of the first President of the United States, George and then to Chester Le Street where the Riverside ground is located, but I did not know how close to the ground and I had worked out that the bus journey alone took about an hour journey took an hour whereas I could travel by car from home and reach my seat within half an hour. The bus journey along the coast to Sunderland was about three quarters of an hour and a similar period to reach the ground from the what has become the bigger than Newcastle local authority but still second city, although within the region it is third with Durham a more popular destination. So which route did I chose? More Coronation Scot music as we move on to part four.

I decided to try the route which combined two virgin experiences and armed with a rucksack, haversack, backpack containing a note book, umbrella and a booklet of information on the big change to the occupational pension scheme which had also arrived in the morning post I walked to the bus interchange station in time for the 2.50 pm route 50 service to Chester Le Street, arriving five minutes beforehand to find long queue, the majority bus pass owning elders, a small proportion of whom were still on the bus as it left Chester Le Street for Durham and who I therefore presumed had made the trip to Shields on Market day and were returning home for their tea. I was also surprised that several alighted as we made our way out of the town via Bolden Lane where at the of which is located the residential Home where my mother live for the last four years of her life, and a route which I had travelled twice a day for over two years but had never done so by bus. The onward journey to Bolden Asda and Cineworld was also familiar territory as again I have made this trip at least once a month. After Bolden I was in unfamiliar land. Which way would we go? Coronation Scot music leads to part five.

First we took the Sunderland Newcastle Road to the junction with the A19 and then went south taking the first exit leading to Washington, Sunderland, which previously was Washington New Town, County Durham and before that Washington County Durham.

The new Town was created in 1964 modelled on the U S A experience of creating new communities for the car owning democracy. Before then Washington was a collection of communities between Sunderland and Chester Le Street much of it land owned by the family of Lord Lambton, with at least one important coalfield and chemical works, The vision was to create a series of separate but enlarged communities, known as districts with a range housing and local facilities, a number of industrial and business enterprise estates, a new purpose designed shopping centre and central bus station, linked by a major road net work. To the East of Washington there is the dual carriage motorway linking Tyneside with Teesside and on to York the A 19 which becomes the former A 1 to London and to the West of Washington linking South Shields one spur, and Newcastle the main spur to the M1 Motorway is the AIM motorway. Going through Washington from the north to the south and close to the town centre is a third dual carriage way route, and going through Washington are also two East West- West East routes on either side of the Town centre. There is no train centre. Although designed o be so there is in fact no sense of it being a town and soon after the administration of the town was moved from its development corporation to Sunderland the numbered only district approach was abandoned and reverted to named place communities of which there are now some 17 associated with the two each with an average population of three to four thousand with a total of sixty thousand at the 2001 census. Such a significant increase in population has been sustained by the development of seven industrial, manufacturing and business centre and most of all the decision of Nissan to create a car assembly plant in the area, and which is now the only such centre in the England, the pride of Nissan employing 5000, working three production shifts a day and where the wage of trainee is twenty thousand pounds more than a teacher, police or service man. Although Washington Old Hall is the home of the George Washington ancestors, his grandfather John was living in Essex when he first went to America.

In addition to the ancestor's of George, Washington is famed for Bryan Ferry former lead singer of Roxy Music and Heather Mills, former wife of Sir Paul (Beatle). Despite these associations and stopping near the headquarters of the Child Benefit agency, a giant office block from where all the client information of many millions was put on disk and lost in transit to the Government Audit office, the half hour tour of the towns districts is not something I wish to repeat. I will look to see if there is a more direct route between South Shields and Washington Bus Station and then join the 50 service because it was only a quick journey, leaving the Town centre along one north south route, joining one east west route and hen the A1m before taking the slip road to Chester Le Street, just after the Washington area service station. However as I suspected the bus did not continue along the main road to Durham and the Riverside ground but took the first turning at the first roundabout off to the Town Centre where before lighting from the bus I asked the driver, who was also leaving at this point if this was the closest stop to the Cricket ground. Coronation Scot music before part six.

He advised that I should stay on the bus for two more stops and then turn left down the hill. The replacement driver suggested that I should go to the next stand for a 78 which would take me directly to the ground but on reaching the stand I saw that I had to wait 29 minutes so I had just missed the connection. I decided to get back on and was allowed to do so jumping the queue of people buying tickets or showing their passes. As I turned the down the road there ahead of me was the sign Chester Le Street Cricket ground and for half a second I said oh no, I have been sent to the wrong ground.

It was only half a second because for two, may be three or four years I was familiar with the town's cricket ground as it was one of those used by the new county before the purpose design ground at the riverside was created, and I therefore knew that the Riverside was just 100 yards further down the hill and with only the busy and fast dual carriage way road to Durham to cross over. At Chester Le Street I watched an Australian batsman playing for Durham against the West Indies touring side hit 100, in a team which also included Ian Botham, Those were the days.
At Riverside I noted that I could have driven my car into the ground for the box office and the journey from door to door had taken over one and a half hours, three times that of using my car. I obtained my tickets and decided to take the other route home route home. There are two buses which stop at the ground, the 71 service from Chester Le Street to Sunderland Interchange which goes into Houghton Le Spring a journey of 55 minutes and the 78 which commences at the former steel town of Consett in County Durham some 56 minutes further on from Chester Le Street and which then takes a more direct route into Sunderland passing the landmark Penshaw Monument, a journey of 39 minutes to Sunderland Interchange. I was fortunate that this was the first bus to reach my stop and I arrived at Sunderland about thirteen minutes to five. I was even more fortunate as I had just worked out where the stand was for South Shields at the prize winning designed bus and metro train station when the quickest of the services to South Shields arrived, the 40 minute E1 service which took me to a stop at the bottom of my hill. And I was in the house just before twenty to six. The E 6 takes 47 minutes and the E 2, 49 and all three travel along part of the South Shields to Sunderland coast Road so that overall this route can be quicker, more scenic and does not involve walking but does involve a change in buses.

As we any good mystery, just when you believe you know the answers to the questions and solution to the main mystery there are one or two other twists in the story and I have also completed six of the eight parts of a Paul Temple series, so more Coronation Scot music.

The mini adventure and successful completion of my mission was celebrated with a pint of lager, a bream fish with vegetables and a piece of Apple Strudel and Ice Cream followed by coffee, and later night snack of a chunky salami pieces sandwich and the discovery of an on line list of every bus journey with latest on line time table of every bus route within and from Tyne and Wear, some 400 individual time tables. I need to take a detailed look, especially as many of the time tables appear out of date. My interest was routes which take one into Northumberland and Durham:- Newcastle to Durham and Bishop Auckland, Newcastle to Cramlington and Blyth. Durham to Seaham Harbour. Sunderland to Darlington, Sunderland to Middlesbrough Sunderland to Hartlepool Newcastle to Hexham, Newcastle to Carlisle Metro Centre-Bamburgh, Newcastle to Otterburn and Newcastle to Roman Wall.

However my eyes lit up at a service from Newcastle via the Heworth Interchange all the way to Whitby and Scarborough in North Yorkshire operating on Sundays and Bank Holiday in the summer which means that on can use the pass to get Newcastle for the start at 9.15 arriving in Scarborough at 12.15, return at 10 to six arriving back in Newcastle at eight forty five although I would get off at Heworth at 20.29 The question is this a free service or a regarded as a coach? More Coronation Scot Music
The final part starts with a red herring. Have train journeys to London from Sunderland commenced? They have but because of technical problems on the liner between Sunderland and York which take nearly twice the time than from York to Newcastle there appears to be only direct route on some of the journeys passengers are being switched to other services which all sounds a mess. Finding out tickets prices on line was also something of a problem so I can imagine that those living in the Sunderland area will still find it easier to get to Newcastle or Durham that Sunderland which was always going to be the problem especially a as the number of trains a day is also limited.

The main question? Who is going to win Britain's Got Talent. My impression that the public are being steered was significantly reinforced last night. As the order of appearance and comments of the judges was skewed against the singers in favour of others so that the four girls playing classical electronic and contemporary looking instruments a la Bond were set up to go through as the last act on the night and the penultimate act of five young dancers, three black, all with day jobs, were voted through by the judges at the expense of the long time serving comedian. Simon appeared to be pushing the girl musicians at contest winners and in the later programme it appears that Faryl has been persuaded to switch from singing Amazing Grace which would have been ideal to something more contemporary which may not show off the range of her voice. It may have been decided that the twelve year old should be encouraged to continue with her education and enter formal singing training at a specialist school rather than be thrust into the limelight Charlotte Church style. She and her family may not just be ready.

The final question trailed at the beginning of today's writing is what has happened to my occupational pension in relation to those presently in work? However this prompts a second series. Final playing of the Coronation Scot.

Wednesday, 15 July 2009

Amartya Sen and justice in the 21st century

There has been three important programmes over the past two weeks concerned with moral dilemmas: The five episode Torchwood, the first of weekly series called The Street and Monday’s Start of the Week with Andrew Marr.

The Andrew Marr programme commenced with a description and a discussion of the work of Nobel Prize winner from India Amartya Sen whose has produced a widely acclaimed work on the nature of justice in world as it is today. Mr Sen is one of the most distinguished and respected social economists in the USA, England and India, having held senior roles in all three countries including being the first person of Indian original to be elected Master of Trinity College Cambridge. A position he held for six years.

I have used justice as a term to mean fairness in the dealings between human being and between nations of human beings, ever since reading an essay on the subject while at Ruskin College. I write this away from home and cannot check if it was in a collection of essays or a work by Hart who provided teaching to the post graduate Criminology course at Oxford University or essays in a bock edited by Laslett, Runciman et al.

In the programme Mr Sen explained the existence of two traditions historical tradition of thinking about the subject. The first commenced with the political thinkers of such Locke and Rousseau, who attempted to define an ideal form of society which in reality has never existed and some could argue could never exist and therefore it presuppose human beings in general with qualities which few possess or are able to sustain with any consistency during their individual lives.

The second approach was taken up by another stream of writers and activists which included Mary Wollenstonecraft and Marx who wanted to stop injustice, inequalities , oppressions in the here and now. The motivating issue changed with time, the abolition of slavery, the rights of women, massive disparities between the wealth of a minority and the poverty of the majority. The programme then examined some of the contemporary issues where a pragmatic approach should be considered, but with a small P and a philosophical one.

The main argument of Sen is something that I have also raised s a consequence of my own experience is that there is never one right response or solution in any given situation of conflict or major choice. The example of the manufacture, use and ownership of flute was used. There is a young person who can play the flute brilliantly and needs this particular flute to continue their development as a musician and highest quality of performance. Clearly if any one should own the flute it is this person?

But what of the individual who made the flute with great skill and much time. Surely if anyone deserved to own the flute it is this person. That would be fair and just would it not? But what of someone with a large family to support, and who is without education or other work opportunities but has an ability to play the flute and can earn sufficient by entertaining tourists who visits their city to maintain his family, surely this individual has the greater need and should own the flute?

I prefer a different example of this dilemma from the health service and the use of donor dependent organs such as a heart or liver and such like and where there are many competing for the few organs which are available and where the priorities will change unless one sticks to a simple order of chronological waiting list which could mean a vital organ going to an old person with only a limited time span in any event and not to a young person. But what if the young person is a criminal, unemployed, badly educated? Does this make a difference. What if the choice is between a mother with children who have grown up with grand children who has loved and cared for them so that they now contribute to society in a positive way and who also undertook basic caring work or volunteering in the community, has never been in trouble with the law or made demands on the resources of the state or local government or health service before. Should she get the available organ which could prolong her life but would have no impact on wider society, or should it go to a man in his forties who is working on a cure for a cancer where he is the only person with the knowledge and skill to make progress quickly but where he is known to have abused his partners, disregarded the needs and interests of his parents, had fathered several children who he disowns etc? Which one would you chose? What would be just, what would be fair?

What the author was suggesting is that only through open discussion could the best solution be determined and that such discussion was best taken within the framework of democratic government.

This brings me to Torchwood, shown over five nights last week. At one level this is a re-enactment of the crucifixion in the setting of a space science fiction drama. Aliens have been to earth before, to England, something which the present Prime Minister decides to cover up when they return. Previously they offered to provide a vaccine for a killer virus in exchange for a dozen children. Now when they return they want one in ten of the children in the world or they will destroy all life on the earth planet.

What happens to the children? They are attached in a permanent state of being to the alien creature and which gives the alien a fix rather like a drug. Was it right to sacrifice twelve children to obtain a vaccine which saved hundreds of thousands, possibly millions and if so or in any event why not then yield one in ten children to save everyone else, on the basis there is no way of negotiating something different or preventing the alien force from carrying out their threat. In Torchwood an individual who cannot die but who can be killed and therefore can experience all the horror and pain of different forms of death but from which he recovers including being held in a block of cement or blown up, is forced to sacrifice his only human son in order to save everyone including the 10% of the children of the world.

An then last night the first dilemma raised by The Street centres on a publican who barred a member of the pub football team he caught smoking in the toilets, so when he catches the son of the local villain and benefactor also smoking he bans him. His father then demands that his son is served or he will beat up and possibly kill the publican. The man, a recovering alcohol is a good husband and father of three children, two daughters who are typical teenagers and a son who is at university where he is returning the following day but helps out in the bar and overhears the threat to his father. He warns that if his father is harmed he will do likewise to the son of the villain. The pub has become the centre of community activity with various teams in addition to the football team, providing cheap pensioner lunches and Christmas parties and generally being the hub of local community activity. There are no drugs or drunkenness or rowdy behaviour allowed. The local villain however is also the primary funder of many of the activities with which the pub and the community are associated

Understandably the wife of the publican wants her husband to give in and suggests that he removes the bar on the other young man. The young man in question says he admits he was right to have been barred and is disappointed that the ban is being lifted under duress because of his belief in the moral strength and good works of the publican. The publican decides to stand his ground and find another way. His wife suggests that he should call on the young men of the football team for support. The manager of the team question this decision drawing attention that the publican ensured that his son went back to university and did not become involved yet he is prepared to involve the sons of others. He had been happy to accept the money which had kept the football team going and arguments about how the man got his money appeared rich from someone who used the activities associated with the pub to promote the sale of alcohol which was the biggest killer and the most disruptive of all drugs and potentially harmful substances. The publican realises it was a mistake to ask the young men so turns to his other customers expecting them to put up a show of force and solidarity in his defence but they suddenly disappear, cannot be contacted. One man does volunteer without being asked but then backs out when he realises he is the only one. He cannot risk the consequences in terms of his family. One man does come forward an older and physically weak man played by Timothy Small, who is head butted out of the way when he decides to ignore the plea to stay away by the publican although he appreciates the true act of friendship and indeed courage.

Monday, 6 July 2009

Xialou Guo

Tuesday proved to be a day which should have been different so that overall there is a sense of failure. There is a new problem in that going to bed early means that I am then waking fully early and then tend to work at the desk for a few hours before feeling able to undertake physical work. That extra stone of weight from the point reached a year and a half ago' limiting my efforts and I am finding it difficult to break the cycle of imbalance between food intake and physical activity.

There were positives during the day and miniscule achievements in that I finish the kitchen and day room cleans, washed and dried the two white covers of the dilapidated settee but is so comfortable although low lying and poses difficulties when tired and getting up.

I also dusted the front room library lounge and my work room lounge. It was here that I noted a large crack in the lower panel of the door which I believe is the effect of using the central heating system more than the previous owners. I will acquire some wood filling and matching stain and paint on a visit to B and Q early this morning when I also go to investigate laminate flooring for the kitchen. I am tempted to tackled both projects, as this is work I can undertake myself where as the sudden stop of water in the bathroom sink may involve major upheaval although fixing the day room light may not. If I finish the house clean and tidy this week, I will then concentrate on arranging these.

I had planned to go to the cinema in the afternoon but first forgot, and did not check the time when Lost is shown first thing so missed the opportunity to go to the afternoon show, and then left my departure to late for the evening, although setting off, realised about half way that I was likely to miss the start, especially as I had a need for some sweeties where the need was irresistible. This goes back to the days when having the cinema pass at £9.99 a month and £12.99 to include central London, the sense of not having to pay at the time of a visit deluded one into buying the expensive sweety mix instead of getting a supply from the supermarket. So I returned home and started to read a Christmas present but then my attention turned to the bad news of Spurs beating Arsenal in the League Cup, which means that Arsenal will now direct their energies to winning the FA Cup when they meet Kevin Keegan's Newcastle on Saturday.

Yesterday I caught part of a reading of a description by a Chinese young woman of coming to Britain to learn English by a contemporary Chinese author which reminded that I needed to write to a friend in China. I tried the BBC on the internet for yesterday's programme schedule but decided to test the new BBC service where it is possible to view any TV programme of the last seven days from any of their channels with a matching radio player available, At present I have one eye on the second episode Lark Rise to Candleford and the line "God intended boy's to have father's and becomes devil's own if they do not." In fact the father is in prison on Dartmoor for manslaughter whereas the boy believes he is adventuring abroad. The truth emerges and the reactions of the people of the two villages of Lark Rise and Candleford is on of the two sub plots of the week. The other is the great Dawn French's portrayal of the woman with many infants whose husband is also away adventuring and who submits to the door to door seller of beer and is brought before magistrates when she does not pay her debt. The squire magistrate is a stern man and keen upholder of the law and good order, but he after standing for none of her charms and devices to enlist sympathy of the court saves his wrath for giver of credit without checking on the ability of the woman to pay or on the likely impact on her family, deciding against imprisonment and paying off the debt at a trickle. Why do banks and firms write off millions as a consequence of bad judgements and circumstances but always hound the individual and usually society sides with the financial institutions.

I was also able to establish that the reading was a Woman's hour serialization of the first novel written in English of the Chinese writer Xiaolu Guo and the book is called a Concise Chinese English Dictionary for young lovers, I was able to hear the interview in which she explained that she attempted to use language similar to her own understanding of English during her first three year in Britain. What interested me is that although the ability to write Chinese ahs always appeared a complex and skilled activity, it was said that the structure of the language was much simpler and more direct than English. I will try and hear the rest of the reading as I can move a portable radio around the house with me.

I then discovered that the greater part of today's programme was devoted to centenary of the birth of Simone De Beauvoir, the largely self educated philosopher and writer who was also a close friend of John Paul Sartre who developed Existentialist philosophy. It would be wrong to attempt to argue who had the greater influence of 20th century society, except for the profound words of Simone the effect that that girls are made and not born. She was both right and wrong because we are all mixtures of nature as well as of nurture and where the mixtures are always varied within a society at any pint in time but with the predominant roles culturally determined with the context of religious, political and economic factors. This is one of the issues of my major work project of the year, the impact of my childhood on the rest of my life. However before starting to write I need to be confident about the framework and that I can deal with a number of issues of confidentiality in relation to other family members. Terry Waite's book, Brian Keenan were two autobiographies following their captivity in which they were as open and direct as anyone about their feelings and coping or not, but also protected the rights and interests of their family
It is again coincidental but not that such coincidences keep happening that after writing about the European Film Academy awards yesterday and where I had only seen perhaps 20% of the films awarded over the past decade and 10% of those nominated, the 2008 Oscar nominations were announced in the afternoon, although there is a question mark over the holding of the event because of a dispute between the screen writers and the industry in the USA. For the first time in ten years I have not yet seen any of the films nominated for the best film award, although I went to see Atonement and saw another film by mistake and also missed Michael Clayton and intended to see No Country for Old men during the day. The same applies to the majority of other nominations for awards with exceptions Marion Cotillard for La Vie En Rose as best actress and Philip Seymour Hoffman in Charlie Wilson's war as a supporting actor. I was more in touch with European cinema before moving my mother North, and intend to visit the Tyneside film theatre more regularly especially when it moves back to its theatre in the city which is being refurbished. There is no excuse about not seeing the mainstream Anglo American Cinema and hopefully some will be shown in theatre again. There were other developments which made the of greater significance that these notes will indicate.