Tuesday, 19 February 2013

Homage to Catalonia -1

During writing about Keep the Aspidistra Flying I explained that in 1935 Eric Blair had met Eileen O’Shaughnessy from  South Shields and swept her of her feet after meeting at party held by the lady who rented him a room at her home. No sooner had they met and she agreed to marry him did he accept a commission from Victor Gollancz to travel to Yorkshire and Lancashire to gain first hand knowledge of the conditions of the  manual working classes, and what happened to them when there was no work. On his return in the summer of 1936  an aunt made available a cottage at Wallington in Hertfordshire about 35 miles from central London (not my Wallington or Wallington Hall in Northumberland) for the inexpensive rent of £2 month.  The cottage is described as tiny and adjacent to the closed village store which after his marriage to Eileen and their return from Spain and Morocco she opened and ran to supplement his income as a writer. However much was to happen to both of them fundamentally change Orwell’s views although I have no information  on the impact on his wife.

Eric Blair then went to Spain although getting there proved a challenge in order to report on the Civil War but he quickly became involved in  the fighting at the front which may have been his intention all along. Why did he do this? His wife came out to Barcelona and staying while her husband was at the front being entertained by George Kopp the man who was in charge and who became his friend. Eric appears to have believed that she had a sex based affair with Kopp who was subsequently imprisoned and accused of being a Fascist plant by the Stalin directed Spanish Communist party who turned on the popular front POUM. Blair  who was shot in the throat and lucky to be alive escaped with and his wife  and subsequently went to French speaking Morocco.

I have listened to the two part dramatization of Orwell’s account of his experiences in Spain as part of the BBC The Real George Orwell series and am now reading the book, Homage to Catalonia, again as well as having heard a BBC book club question and session on the book and listened to the BBC dramatization of their visit to Morocco and the meeting with George Kopp although I am not sure if this actually took place. Nearly twenty years ago I saw the Len Loach film Land and Freedom about the Spanish Civil War and I may have the video recording somewhere. The film drew on Orwell’s book which was seen at the picture house in Richmond on Thames during a short visit  to the Wallington to stay with  my birth and care mothers.

I have been interested in the Spanish Civil war for the greater part of my life because  the Aunties were living in Gibraltar throughout the that time with my birth mother coming to England in 1938 and four of her sisters coming to the UK in 1939 to live in Wallington at her home of another sister, her husband and at the time their four children. Another sister briefly remained in Gibraltar marrying a young professional soldier who became an officer with the war and later moved to married quarters at Catterick camp in north Yorkshire, where I was to be evacuated during the worst of the VI and V2 rocket attacks with more falling around Croydon airport where we lived than anywhere else in the UK.

The youngest of my aunts, Ethel, was engaged to  someone who was studying to be a doctor at the University of Madrid but who disappeared during  the war with no trace of what happened to him. Later when I became more politically aware the War Interested me because for a brief period a genuine workers cooperative state began to emerge especially in Barcelona until  on the orders of Stalin the Communists took control and who in turn were then crushed by the forces of General Franco, imposing his military dictatorship for several decades with the  full support of the Catholic church. My maternal great grandmother was Spanish and although born in Gibraltar my maternal grandmother was  from a Spanish and Italian background family. Having declared such an interest I was  surprised to find that I do not have one book on the civil war and various factions that were  involved  although I do have, The Return to Civil Society the Victor Pérez-Diaz book, Harvard University press and John Hoopers The New Spaniards which looks at all aspects of Spanish life after the end of the Franco regime, in addition to the 1950‘s Morton’s Travel book on his journey to Spain  A stranger in Spain undertaken during the post war Franco era and which was my second stream form prize in my last year at the John Fisher School..

The BBC discussed the Civil War in the Melvin Bragg series In Out Time first broadcast in 2003 and a still available for another year in which Paul Preston, Principe  de Asturias Professor of Contemporary Spanish History at the London School of Economics, Helen Graham Professor of Spanish History at Royal Holloway, University of London, Dr Mary Vincent, Senior Lecturer in the Department of History at Sheffield University.

The abolition of the Monarchy was less a factor in causing the war than the attempts to remove the power of the Catholic Church and the status and control the army as well as those who wanted  to introduce a British kind of Welfare State.  The Right embodying traditional vested interests attempted to regain power democratically between 1931 and 1936 and it was the failure to do so in the 1936 elections which led to the successful Military coup by General Franco with the help of Hitler and Mussolini, the subsequent intervention of Russia and the horrendous failure of the British government to tell Russian and Italy  not to intervene with the exception Churchill who recognised that by not doing so Britain was weakened, as was France, and where according to Preston Goering told Hitler that Franco had three week to triumph before any British intervention would mean it was wise for them to withdraw support.
,
It was Hitler who facilitated the coup by providing air transport for Franco’s North African Army to cross the Straits of Gibraltar and who then provided arms notably  planes which led to Guernica (the Picasso picture which dominated the room in which I work) and control of the airspace. For Mussolini it was another Mediterranean/African adventure and he  provided on the ground military support. Once they controlled  the south Franco’s supporters in the military commenced to raid villages and eliminate those on the left in the most brutal and dramatic of fashion while in the north the Falange (Fascist) party supporters did likewise and there was much revenge and settling of local scores.

It was suggested by Preston that had the UK insisted on a general neutrality  the second World war might not have occurred, although whether this would have still meant Hitler exterminated the Jewish people and other groups he opposed within German territorial borders is a separate issue. However non intervention may not have prevented  the establishment of Franco’s Dictatorship given the quantity of groups on the left within Spain. Viewed with the benefit of hindsight the amazing aspects was that the disorganised and fragmented Popular Front managed to stop Franco’s for three years although the cost was great. However the great majority of lives were lost not on the battlefield but through summary executions, assassinations and extermination of prisoners after periods of torture and imprisonment. The role of the catholic church in denouncing those on the left is inexcusable despite the murdering of priests and  nuns by those on the left, giving the teachings the Catholic are supposed to endorse.

It is general agreed that the media world wide reported the war according to the positions being taken by editors and  governments, with Orwell account first written for the new Statesmen rejected because it was considered inappropriate for the time and one has to remember that for the greater part of World War II Russia was  an ally of the UK and the USA. In the BBC programme the Road to 1984, it was pointed out that when Hitler and Russia signed their pact at the beginning of the War, the Communist party Line in the UK was to be against the War,  calling it  Imperialist and capitalist, but as soon as Russia changed sides, there was national official support with a famous Wilfred Pickles programme at a factory providing supplies to Russia which commenced with the playing of the Internationale. This is why Orwell’s book has become one of the few reliable contemporary accounts of what went on and it is only now that the new generation in Spain is facing up to what happened and seeking to find out the truth, including digging up the mass graves to work out the number of murdered souls even if individual identities will remain a mystery through the destruction of church and civil records at that time.

Even after reading some of the summaries of information about the Civil War I have made little progress  adding to previous impressionism about what happened between 1936 and 1939 when Franco formally took charge of the country and the persecution of anyone associated with the previously democratically elected government, left wing movement and fighting for the Republication cause commenced.

It has to remembered that the Republic did run the military, the navy and airforce and that Franco rebelled with his African based forces but was then joined by many officers with others remaining with the Republican forces. The involvement of forces from other countries and volunteers added to the complications as well as factional groups often related to particular areas and one has only to look at recent history with the quick development of a united front militia and its success against Gaddafi and  his Libyan regime supported by a consortium of other countries in various ways compared to fragmented opposition against a well equipped and disciplined force of the Syrian president and where other countries remain hesitant about intervention because the outcome is so uncertain

Communist parties in other countries were encouraged o recruit volunteers to fight on the Republican side in late 1936 with the main centre located in Paris. The man who became Marshal Tito organised passports, money and travel for those from eastern Europe who went via train or ship from France  although many also went by themselves. The first 500 mainly French arrived in October 1936. The French Communist party also provided uniforms and  the volunteers were trained and equipped and  formal discipline was established although there was no form of contract which meant individuals were free to come and to go. Less than ten percent of the 40000 republican forces which took Madrid were internationals. Also fighting were the Anarchist Militia who in one attack were faced by Moroccans and Spanish Foreign Legionnaires. It is estimated that in total some 32000 “foreigners” were involved with the elected Republicans Government forces and the militia - France 9000, Belgium 1600, Italy 3000 and Germany/Austria 3000 Poland 3000., the Soviets 2000-3000, the USA and Canada around 5000 Cuba 1100, and the UK MI5 estimated 4000 although other sources put the figure as low as 1800/2000  with the Swiss sending 400 to 800 and the Irish 250, there were 100 from China and 90 Mexicans. There were over 30 Brigades with the British brigade included those from commonwealth Countries and the Irish Free State, The International aspects is highlighted in the Abraham Lincoln Brigade which includes British, Cypriots and Chilean volunteers as well as those from the USA and Canada and the Veinte brigade also included British, American, Italian Bulgarians and from Yugoslavia. In addition to 0rwell, British participants included James Robertson Justice and Stephen Spender and Laurie Lee plus the Trade Unionist Leader Jack Jones. From other nations,  Will Brandt who became West German Chancellor, the grandson of Paul Gauguin and Kurt Veil. Paul Robson went to sing. The was also a man who became Prime Minister of Albania, another the Prime Minister of Iran, one became Chairman of Hungarian Council of Ministers, and another the Vice President of Yugoslavia. Arthur Koestler was imprisoned by Nationalists although an official war correspondent and Ernest Hemingway also went as a war Correspondent after Orwell  visited him in Paris as he was making his way to Spain.

Those whose political experience is limited to major political parties such as Republicans and democrats the in the USA, the British Labour and Conservatives  and Liberal Democrat parties will not appreciate the extent of fragmentation  in other countries especially among parties of the left where difference often relate to personalities, and to issue of ways and means rather than  major policies. In Spain in 1936 a broad coalition of parties formed the Popular front. I do not have the representation terms of number of seat or official supporters to hand but there were several broad groupings representing ideologies, interests and regions.

The regional interest parties were the Catalonia Region parties based on Barcelona- the ERC Republican Left of Catalonia and the PSUC Unified Socialist party of  Catalonia; the Basque Separatist the PNB Basque Nationalist, the ANV Basque Separatist Action and the STV Basque Workers Solidarity.

The communists were the PCE The Communist party of Spain  which became the major force aided by the SRI International Red Aid, the Russian led Comintern group who effectively  also controlled the  Spanish Communist party and the Communist members of the International Brigades.

One of the most influential parties in that members formed the bulk of the first government and supporters were drawn from the civil service as well as  small businesses and skilled workers was the IR Izquierda Republicana  Republican Left, itself made of from mergers  of three parties. In addition there was the UR Union Republicana  Republican Union was supported by skilled workers and progressive businessmen. The PSOE the Spanish Workers Party had itself split left and Right and became the second largest party in the Cortes and comprised mainly urban manual workers. The UGT General Workers Union was linked with the PSOE as was the Federation of Socialist Youth  one of four youth orientated groups  the JSU United Socialist Youth a mixture of Communists and Socialist youth groups and the FIJL representing Libertarian Youth and POUM see below also had a youth movement.

There was the anarchist and syndicalism groups ( hesitate to use party in this context) the CNT National Confederation of Labour representing anarchist and syndicalism orientated trade unions; The FAI Iberian Anarchist federation representing groups active in the republican militia; The Mureres Libre  Anarchist Feminist Group,  and the PS Syndicalist party a splinter group from CNT

The Union Militar was formed of military Officers supporting the Republicans

POUM - the Partido Obrero de Unificacion Marxista, the anti Stalin revolutionary Party of former Trotskyists with the JCI  Iberian Community Youth their your  movement and which the British Independent Labour Party was associated and who in turn sponsored  Orwell.

They were opposed by the Nationalist Union Militar Espaliola made up of army officers, the Monarchists Alfonsist, the Spanish restoration party,, The Spanish Action and the National Block (Militia) and the Monarchists Carlists  with a party of this name  plus its militia Reqestés, its youth the Pelayos and its women‘s movement the Margaritas; and the Fascists the  Falange  FE, the OJE Fascists youth and their women’s section. There was also a traditionalist Falange party. There was also CEDA a coalition of Christian based parties, plus the wealth and the power of the Catholic Church hierarchy.

As mentioned in previous writings although Blair described himself as a socialist with notions of quality and freedom for all, he was not a member of any political party until after returning from Spain and although he attended some political meetings, including that of the Communist Party and one meeting at which Oswald Moseley spoke he was not a political activist and was hostile to other middle and upper class intellectuals who attempt to lead the socialist movement in the UK, believing that true socialism could only emerge from the actions of the proletariat.

It is my understanding that Orwell’s interest in the civil War as much concerned with the intervention of General Franco and  the support he received from  Hitler, Mussolini and the Falange as he was with the populist support for the new republic. When he arrived he found he had reached a socialist Utopia.

According to the Radio programme Blair believed he had to obtain papers from some left wing organisation to be admitted to the Republican controlled areas and he went to see the General Secretary of British Communist Party with a view to going to Madrid and joining an International Brigade. Politt understandably and correctly appreciated that Blair was not one of them and a potential enemy. His next approach was to the Independent Labour Party who seeing the opportunity to cash in on the man’s increasing status within the UK labour movement because of his books agreed to provide him was the credentials, albeit not necessary, to journey to Barcelona where they had an office.

I know from his previous writings that Blair structured his books carefully not always following a chronology and his responses  have to judged as after thoughts as much as contemporary response at the time. Blair wrote about this aspect and the extent to which any writing, including his own could be described as objective truth. Therefore any individual work should be considered alongside any diaries, letters, remembered contemporary conversations by others and any other writings made at the time.

In the first chapter of the book Orwell, the writer, notes that on his arrival in Barcelona the city has the appearance of a worker’s state. The bourgeois are in hiding or adopting the clothes of the workers. The buildings are draped in red the socialists and red and black  for the anarchists with slogans for the Republic. The churches are being demolished and entering a cafe the waiters look you in the and do not call you sir. Tipping forbidden. Food was in short supply meat scarce, milk  almost unobtainable and bread queues could be several hundred yards long. Work was found for everyone and everyone individually received the same amount, that is each worker, non worker, aged parent and young child, and there were no beggars apart from the gypsies.

Almost immediately he joined the militia and was told he would quickly be moving to the frontline but this did no happen. There was no discipline and instruction useless with the main problem the absence of weaponry, Russia is  estimated to have contributed half a million riffles and ammunition plus other supplies but this went to the Stalin direct Communists and the Stalin controlled International brigades supporting the forces at Madrid. The POUM militia which he joined was badly organised and equipped but he quickly made friends. He noted that sometimes parents brought their 15 year olds to join because the lad received bread, where there was sufficient for some  to get back to their families. He comments on the Spanish approach to getting things done on time and ‘Manana’ and then without proper equipment  they were given two hours notice of moving to the front.

He describes the excitement with the women folk coming to help their men and all the flags waving in the torchlight with a political speech in Catalan before the late departure from that planned. He was off to war and to kill Fascists.

At the town where the  militia waited for trucks to take the front line outside Zaragoza which is  midway between the Catalans and the Basques and the city head of the Aragon region. They still did not have riffles to fight and the main excitement was the arrival of small groups of deserters from the ranks of the Fascist forces, scared of what would happened to them and usually men who did not have close families still in Fascist  controlled territories. I say Fascists but as  I have explained it would be better to say Nationalists, because there were Monarchists factions, Army factions and Christian factions and then the Fascists although there were many cross over. Orwell  immediately learns his first lesson of war, of any kind, the enemy are the same  as you, they look the same apart from the different uniforms and they behave the same unless instructed to behave otherwise. The front line was on a hill with the enemy occupying another hill well out of the range of a riffle.

The third chapter begins with a  list of their priorities in the trenches, firewood above everything else as Winter approached, then food then tobacco, then candles and then  along way fifth, the enemy, He saw no fighting in January and February and played on a minor part in fighting which took place in March. Aeroplanes dropped no bombs near him and no shell exploded within fifty yards. The other side had machine guns but by taking  precautions this was not a problem and he spent much of his time looking across the Wintry landscape at the futility of it all. The scenery was stupendous with the snow capped Pyrenees in the distance.

On arrival eh was made a capo, corporal, in charge of 12 men, mostly teenagers and notes that children as young as eleven were involved with militia, usually having escaped from the Fascists and looked after as   means of providing for them and kept out of harm’s way, but sometimes they managed to get themselves in the front line and were a menace to everyone. He felt that boy scouts and girl guides armed with airguns or battledores( racket for playing badminton but also a horn like book reading aid) could have overcome his position. Having expressed his concern that they were not equipped or organised to overcome the enemy, he pointed out that bourgeois armies were then run on a mixture of obedience  through drill, bullying and fear where his colleagues were driven by class loyalty and commitment to the cause and the men would not have tolerated bullying and other abuses of power. By May he had become an acting Lieutenant in charge of 30 men English and Spanish and had no difficult in in getting an order obey or getting volunteers.

Having said that firewood was the priority he explains just how cold he became despite pullovers  jackets and coats, thick socks and boots, gloves and headgear.   They were dirty often everything caked in mud with limited first water to drink brought by mules and excrement was everywhere. He took of his clothes at night only three times in eighty days and although too cold for lice as yet but they were plagued by mice and rats and rats became the enemy, leading to the rat being used to torture in 1984. There was  enough food and wine with cigarettes at a packet a day. (Men confined together in close quarters  smoke more I mentioned as a personal aside) The main point of the  chapter is that there were not allowed to attack the enemy and Georges Kopp when he toured the lines would say it was a comic opera with an occasional death  Without heavy weapons they had no choice but to stay out of reach  about 400 yards and make occasional night sorties which  had no  impact on the overall position

He lists what they did not have, maps or charts, no range finders, binoculars, no wire cutters, flares and  nothing to maintain their riffles. The greatest threat was from accidental firing of their own weapons and he records a machine gun going off close to his face.

Returning to the chronology after three weeks with another English man he was sent to join a party of  20 to 30 men sent out by the ILP from England and this brought him close to the town. He notes that the English got on well with the Spanish  despite the language difficulties and who  only knew two expressions one from English sailors regarding professional sex workers! And the other OK Baby which suggests American Hollywood influence. nadOrwell seems to use English to mean English speaking rather than geographical location.

He explains how tired they all became and the accumulative effect of being on guard for hours without sleep, remembering twenty four hour periods without sleep occurring on average every ten days and he fired only three shots during one period of three weeks with the estimate that it would take a thousand rounds to kill one man and on this basis twenty years before he killed one fascist. His Spanish colleagues  appeared to spend most for the time calling on the enemy to desert and join them and this rather shocked Orwell. Recently I watched for the umpteenth time that great film of the Second World battle for the Atlantic convoy, The Cruel Sea with Jack Hawkins. and when they see the survivors of only the second Germany submarine they were to destroy throughout the war, and saw their enemy  at close quarters, one observed they don’t seem different from us.

Saturday, 9 February 2013

The Real George Orwell Down and Out in London

In my previous piece of writing on the Real George Orwell, Eric Blair, BBC 4 Radio production he had returned to England on official holiday leave from his position as a police officer for the Colonial Service in Burma and to recover from a bout of tropical fever at the home of his parents. During a holiday in Cornwall he came to the decision to resign without knowing what his  next income would be. He was 24 years of age. He wanted to  become a professional writer.

As I also wrote there are sufficient connections and coincident to confirm my contention of the repetitive and cyclical nature of experience between individuals and generations

At the age of 20 after fours years working in local government in central London and  Croydon I decided to test my increasing confidence and wish to better myself  and became a office equipment salesman for the Italian firm Olivetti attending a month‘s sales course  at their headquarters in Barclay Square and finishing top out of about 40 others, some of whom did not survive the weekly examination and appraisal. In the first month I achieved over 30 placements of the latest machine on a trial based and was unable to sell one because those using did not like the soft, spongy touch. The new design was a disaster and I quickly lost heart as door after door was shut in my face and only having a limited number of small offices to visit in a concentrated areas in the City of London around Bishopsgate, as the weather changed, I found myself spending more and more time travelling around the circle line of the underground sitting in park, pubs and coffee houses, a  journey which took around 53 to 55 minutes.

For the cost of three old pence ticket, the minimum fare you could spend all day travelling around and around if you wished and it was interesting to note other fellow travellers in the compartment of choice, mostly salesmen killing time or writing up their sales and notes, but also the elderly keeping warm and school children playing truant. There was the occasional tramp although I do not remember seeing many,

I resigned much to the horror of the management without having another job to do. I quickly became dependent on my family but after a couple of months I obtained a temporary job at Housemans Bookshop  close to Kings Cross Station and from the same building the Pacifist weekly Peace News was also published.

While Blair was helping to control the Empire at the same age I had become an activist for the Direct Action Committee against Nuclear War  helping to organise the Scottish end of the London to Holy Loch march and  demonstration against the location of the USA controlled Polaris Submarines at Holy Loch, and a short time member of the Committee 100 set up by Bertrand Russell, electing to serve six months in prison rather than give an undertaking to stop such activities. I resigned  from the committee after Russell rejected my warnings about the conduct of his assistant and which makes nonsense of subsequent 8 page “I was misled” tirade against the man published as an appendix in the official work on his life by Ronald W Clark.  I had  some limited experience of being on the road and once spent a night frozen in a bus shelter in a town in Derbyshire on my way to Liverpool to join a march between Liverpool and Hull. I will refer against to the experience of walking 12 to 20 a miles a day in all-weather, on little food, dependent on the hospitality of others and  usually sleeping on the floor of some  hall in a sleeping bag.

On his return Eric Blair consulted a Cambridge Don about becoming a writer, attended an Eton College reunion dinner and in the Autumn he moved to London acquiring a flat in the Portobello Road. During the five years he commenced to investigate the lives of the poor, in and out of work in London and Paris  publishing an essay The Spike, moving to Paris until 1928, and turning his experiences into an autobiographical novel Down and out in Paris and London some after. His first published work was completed. His mother’s sister lived in Paris and provide him with social and financial support to enable him to write the first version of Burmese Days although the  issue of what is what is was like to be poor without prospects obsessing him as a subject for writing.

Like myself although he was poor, without a job or a home of his own, he was not isolated without relatives and others who he could fall back on and lend support, including financial support and therefore unlike the majority of the rest who were poor without support unless provide by the state or charities, and more significantly without prospects. I will come back to this issue as does Blair several times in his work.

In 1929 Blair became ill and was admitted to a hospital leading to an essay How the poor die (1946). You want to write the experiences you have but you need time, perspective and a  measure of objectivity and then from a publishing viewpoint there is the problem about writing about contemporary others without their expressed permission or whose activity in question  has been made public by them or is already in the public domain, although even in this respect there are appropriate restrictions where it is wise to follow if one dos not wants to find oneself in the civil and sometimes criminal courts as an accused. Blair and his publishers appears to have adopted her device of converting experiences into fiction with Homage to Catalonia the exception.

In Paris when his money was stolen  from a lodging house where he was staying Blair took a job as a dish washer in in fashionable hotel. Later, as the end of the year approached he returned to the comfortable existence of life with his parents who  settled at Southwold and where he remained for the following five years 26 to 31.

After I commenced the life as direct actionist (Marx on Fuerbach’s 11th Theses point) I worked occasionally as a temp in a left wing coffee bar meeting place in Soho and where the manager offered a permanent  job  in part to dissuade me from the course I had set on to go to prison. I was also elected to the executive of my local Labour Party which then sponsored me to Ruskin College Oxford, where after studying a year for a Politics and Economics diploma I was able to switch to a post graduate University Diploma in Public and Social Administration where the other students were first and second class honours graduates in other subjects, my tutorial partner for Criminology had gained a First in Theology which set the gold standard for analytical reproduction of the academic work others in the form the essay. I had three articles published in the university weekly Isis, joined several Oxford Societies and was appointed to a Labour Club Committee to campaign fort eh labour party to keep the UK out of a non socialist European Economic Community. Then de Gaulle said Non. Thus via the back door I had two amazing years in he City the Oxford and its University life experience, return to live and work there for three after a year in Birmingham. Eat your heart out Eric.

I went to Birmingham University for the embryonic new Certificate of Qualification in Social Work, specialising in Child Care which was gained, together with a Home Office  Certificate of professional competence and then joined Oxfordshire  Council, as a child care officer arriving on the day when its head became leader of the Association of Children’s Officers. Because of her role I read and summarised Hanzard in relation to child and family social work which developed into a subscription magazine which I produced with around 35 issues a year for a three year period, publishing other articles in addition to becoming the Parliamentary officer and then Vice President of the professional Association followed by becoming the first chairman of one of the new sections of the British Association of Social Workers. I had developed a clear vision of what I wanted to do and be. And also I knew where I stood politically, a socialist, but passionate anti communist where the writing of Orwell (1984 and Animal Farm) and others helped to confirm from my limited contact with members of the party and the Trots, their actual approach to political issue in the UK and the realities of life in the Soviet dictatorships, as I once tried to explain to Sir Keith Joseph when an official dinner guest.  I had also written a play which although rejected by the English Stage company they asked to see my other work which at the time I had not created, and I was then set on a  different course.

The second week of the BBC Book at Bedtime in the Real George Orwell series commenced with his travelling to London which surprised me because I was under the impression the was at least one further episode on his experiences in Paris. Undertaking catch up reading after the Monday night episode February 3rd, 2012 I appreciated what had happened,

The decision had been taken to omit his experience of leaving the hotel and working in the restaurant with Boris run by another Russian. They had only taken the job at the hotel because the restaurant was not ready to employ them so when Boris gets the call that it is about to open, Blair feels obliged to hand in his notice although he had become settled in the employment. I say Blair although this work was published as a novel and it  is not surprising that his first attempts to publish were rejected. While he did work as a kitchen hand in a hotel I cannot confirm that he worked in the kitchen of any restaurant and therefore his description of the Russian owned one may have been based on hearsay.

In the story he explains how having given up the hotel job, Boris and the two waiters employed found that the premises were in the same condition as when they had  started at the hotel. The owner did not have the funds to hire labour to finish the job and therefore adopted the ruse of getting the waiters, dependent on any money as tips for getting the job done. Because he was the plongeur without tips he was paid a wage but the owner only gave him  part of what he was due and because, but  did give a glass of brandy when he left for home.  He describes that when the restaurant opened he worked 17 to 19  hours days sometimes sleeping on the trampled food on floors too tired to make his way to his lodgings. In the book he claims that he was so fed up with the life that he approached a contact in London for work and he returning to London on the promise of being a companion to a mentally disabled young man in a family, but who he finds had gone abroad for a month hence his need to find the cheapest of lodgings and then to become a tramp dependent on charities providing at and bread during the day and the workhouse  spikes  for bed and breakfast. As I have noted in fact his experiences were the other way round, investigating the life of the poor living in cheap lodging houses and then going on the Spike and then going to Paris and then going home to become a professional writer.

On the journey to Tilbury he tried to persuade a Rumanian couple that England was a paradise of art, culture architectural good design compared to Paris. He then finds his would be employment was on hold for a month and only a few shillings  and six pence to survive so he determines to find the cheapest of lodging houses leaving the rest of his possession at a railway station.

He also attempted to pawn his clothing for inferior stuff  but this only yielded one shilling, mentioning four pawn shop experiences. He then sees a tramp coming towards him and realises it is his reflection in a  shop window. I have previously commented on the difference in how you are treated if you wear a suit collar and tie or casual clothes, especially once past the age of 65. Blair also comments on the disparity between accent and  clothes and  towards the end of the book comments how a tramp manager at a Spike treated him  favourably because  his accent revealed him to be a gentleman on hard times. I suppose I ought to explain, although out of sequence that the Spike is the food and board for the night available at  workhouse casual wards for those on the road who were not pauper inmates,

His first experience of a lodging house brought him the experience of a 15 feet square room with  eight beds and later at a spike there would be eighty. I have experience of sleeping in a room with a score of others (at an open prison camp, former RAF station and again at the Iona Community House in Sauchiehall Street although for the most  part all the other beds were vacant during this stay in Glasgow while helping to arrange the Polaris Protest at Holy Loch.  And then of course I did spend the first ten years of my life after babyhood sharing one double bed with three adult women two at one end and me and my care mother at the other.

Blair complains that the beds in lodging house were hard as board and the pillows blocks of wood, so you should try sleeping on floors in just a sleeping bag my spiritual friend? It is during this experience he begins the diet of bread with marge and large cups if tea. His money lasts for three days and four nights.

He begins to learn about the comradeship that develops between those in like circumstances spend whatever comes their way and share what they have although there is also a lot of stealing from those in similar circumstance who fail to share. He finds that many of the men are 10 shillings a week pensioners and their ongoing survival Blair found  inspiring. One of my aunts, abandoned by her bigamist husband eventually got a 5 shillings a week widow’s pension and relied exclusively on my birth mother’s earning as a teacher for her survival.

Blair was then driven to use the Spike and to his horror found that the rule was you could not stay for more than one night in 30 days in the same place, but you could stay at two different places in London. This meant the hundreds if not thousands of men on the road were constantly walking in all weathers a dozen or more miles a day which was wasted energy to no social purpose and caused harm to the men in question, given they walked on a starvation diet. I have participated in  two walkings of over 100 miles from Liverpool to Hull taking about ten days and a number of shorter walkings Aldermaston to London and London to Bedford over four to five days. In all these instances any baggage including sleeping bags was transported from morning sleep over on a floor, with only one instance a bed provide by a college lecturer at Hull. As with the tramps one therefore was able to walk freely but in Wintry  conditions with the two main walks immediate after Christmas through to the New Year. Blistering feet rather than the absence of food was the problem although unlike the tramps there was  more than bread and tea provided and the  fundamental difference being that we walked with a purpose.

While they would be seen by a doctor this was  to ensure they did have some potentially lethal contagion which could be passed onto the general community. You were not allowed in if you had 8 pence in possession and what you had you were required to hand in including any tobacco but this you smuggled in your socks as although you were searched they rarely got below the knee while others had made secret pockets in their coats,

The evening meal was a half pound  loaf of bread and a mug of cocoa. You left with a 6pence open voucher for some food and a hot drink and were told where they could be exchanged on the next journey selected.

He also learned of the existence of places, usually provided by religions groups which  offered tea and a  bun on the condition you accepted half an hour of prayers and contemplation. Many of those he encountered came from the north who had  lost jobs, a few were mentally challenged,

He makes one friend, from Ireland who lost his job and failed to get another. Learned from the art of turning cigarettes stubs into smokes with London of course the Big Smoke, but also the man‘s reluctance to steal milk   left on the front steps.

It was in episode eight that Blair refers to the hatred which has almost become universal that Englishmen and women, in the UK have for those who come and work from another country, the Scots, the Irish, The Jews, the Blacks, the Indians, the Muslims etc, in fact blame the bloody foreigner nor unemployment and lack of  housing. The odd man who works, the young man who is not at home or a student and everyone who sponges off the state, Sounds familiar?  While Blair dislikes this he dislikes  the Salvation Army of their military approach to the charity they provided.

They could get into the Sally Army hostel at six if they possessed the means to buy a cup of tea each otherwise they had to wait with the rest of the 200 until 8. You went to bed at 10 with two officers making sure there was no smoking and no noise with gambling forbidden during the time before bed and lights out.

Having enough of this experience he goes back to his contact for £1 and gets £2 which takes him and the Irishman into lodgings once more, He also learns about screevers or the pavement artist, now long gone and replaced by those who paint themselves into statues. He tells of one who had studied art in Paris and discovered that if his wife took in sewing they and his six children could survive on the £1 a week average net profit he earned from  drawing the likeness of Churchill and other known figures, although his Botticelli nude had caused reaction from one London church and the police. He explains the hierarchy of beggars and begging scams notably the street photographer

While there is reference to drink being the cause of getting some men onto the street, and tobacco their drug,  there is no mention of other drug substances, or to difficulties after prison, or served in the armed forces. He rarely came across a woman and one fellow traveller was interested in prostitutes as he regarded  all other women out of his league, but in fact the overwhelming number of men remained celibate because of their life style and the effect their appearance had on other women, unless they were religious do gooders.

He also learns something of the rhyming slang, some of which he said was out of fashion although was still being used during my childhood social circle in the 1940’s. He also discovers the use of f,,,k and f,,,king as a swear word although in my 1960’s edition  there are simply  ----. One of the great moments of my Scottish experience in 1961 was getting on a bus full of shift ending factory girls where the coarseness of their comments towards and about me as well as in genera took my breathe away.

Blair then argues that Tramps and fellow dossers are not a different race from the rest of humanity although they are treated as such, but are men who have fallen on hard times and find it difficult to impossible to break back out or in depending on ones perspective. He ends the book with, the device that he is able to survive the days left before his prospective employer arrives back from going abroad and a plea for a more rational approach to treating the poor. All this was before the creation of  the welfare  state and where now the present Coalition, in part from good intentions and commenced to unravel the principal of universality with underpinned the Beveridge Reforms and Welfare system. We are going back an era to soup kitchens and means testing, begging officialdom rather than on the street. As a say everything is cyclical and generational. We never learn.

Thursday, 7 February 2013

The Real George Orwell's Burmese Days

The BBC Radio Four has selected several works of George Orwell to celebrate the holding of a national day to mark his life under the title The Real George Orwell. Eric Blair has given us several cultural masterpieces with Animal Farm and 1984 and which together with Huxley’s Brave New World, say all there is to say about revolutions and the development of totalitarian states under dictatorships. More than this he wrote a number of semi autobiographical works and essays which provide us with an understanding of his development as a writer and indeed as a human being.

He tried to explain his reasons for being a writer in an essay (Why I write) in which he covered something of his childhood in which he felt isolated and undervalued and he discovered that he no only had a facility with words but was able to face unpleasant facts. He also admits to be a day dreamer and putting himself into situations, points which I shall come again when considering the BBC production Burmese Days in which the a different perspective and motivation is suggested. He also lists  what he believes are his objective motives for being a writer at a time when he was an established writer and which I shall comment on in a separate  writing

I do not know enough about his life to claim a great understanding of the man or the process by which he evolved but the BBC series has provide some key issues  and turning points which I assume are factually based.

I have also noted some interesting  parallels and points of connection between us especially the sense of isolation in childhood,  the sudden wish to break out from the pattern of life that had been set out for him through his education and father’s work and the hope that his personal experiences would also contribute to the enlightenment of other on their separate journeys of self discovery and understanding of the earth world and its place in the universe.

I have yet to find out why birth registered as Eric Blair  chose to write as George Orwell. In my instance the selection of Joseph Grech for my identity as a contemporary artist and writer became clear to me four years after the discovery at the age of 59 that the surname of my father was Grech, ‘of the Greeks’ and that Joseph my second name was the name of the parish church where he served as a priest for fifty years and where my mother and her family of six sisters and four brothers had commenced their education at the school attached to church where they had lived next door for a time, and where she had taught as a pupil teacher and later had played the piano and organ for school and church with other members of the family in the church choir. On my second visit to Gibraltar in 2004 and I stood at the top of the rock looking down not just on the rest of this small community but on the life, and the identity I should have had and wanted throughout my self aware consciousness till then, and vowed that for whatever years I had left they would be spent within the apparel of who I should have been although I also accepted what I had been  and that I was as I had become.

Eric Arthur Blair was born into a very different world a few years before that of my birth and care mothers in 1903  (1907 and 1909 respectively) before the outbreak of World War I which changed the future of everyone so dramatically heralding the technological age of warfare and culture. One cannot underestimate the difference   perspective between those who were brought up  and reached adulthood before World War II and those whose childhoods were spent getting in and out of arid raid shelters, watching the rocket bombs pass over head and hen looking at the craters where there had once been homes.
Eric was born in India where his father worked for Colonial Office with responsibilities related to the manufacture and distribution of opium. His mother of French background was brought up in Burma and shortly after his birth his mother brought him and  older sister by five years to England, to Henley on Thames in Oxfordshire. My mother left Gibraltar because of her pregnancy although five of her sisters were required to leave Gibraltar along with some ten thousand other citizens because of the declaration of one and the information that Germany was to take Gibraltar and had to neutral but fascists friendly Spain when the Germany defeated Britain and her colonial empire of territories, colonies and dominions. Gibraltar remains a disputed  independent territory to this day.

I also have two connections with Henley on Thames in that of a year I made the fifty mile return three to four time a week late afternoon into evening to supervised a number of teenage boys for a colleague away in training in addition to the average 50 mile round trip a day work on my existing caseload of child care cases  of children in care, fostering and adoptions as well as being the Court officer for the County Council at Witney and Burford where the benches were respectively chaired by the wife in law and son of the Duke of Marlborough. Later Henley was also the location of a month spent at an International Senior Management course which was to affect  my life in a positive way.

Our first five years appear very different for although without his father apart from a brief visit which led to the birth of his younger sister, he grew up in a comfortable and socially involved environment compared to the deprivations of World War II time and the need for my existence to be kept secret so that all official documentation was removed or never existed in that I was not registered  with a National health doctor until the family GP retired and the war was long over. My earliest memories are of seeing overhead flying V 1 rockets on the way to the garden shelter and looking at bomb craters subsequently  at a time when financial poverty and food rationing limited the family tables and the war time restrictions limited discovery of the surrounding world although I was evacuated to officers married quarters at Catterick for a year missing most of the 140 rockets which fell on the neighbourhood, the biggest concentration in the UK because of our proximity to London’s main airport at Croydon.

Eric then had a female childhood friend and they read and recited poetry together, and while I played cricket with a first cousin after the war there were no books in he household despite my mother being a primary school teacher. My cultural world opened up when we attended the local cinema on Mondays and Thursday, I went to the Saturday morning children’s shows and occasionally saw a fourth cinema programme in a week  going to see the latest releases with first cousins in neighbouring towns, Croydon, Sutton and Purley and only later did I discover the world  of the library when I found I was able to move from  the children’s to the adult sections without questions.

The first point of similarity is that we both went to Catholic preparatory schools where the teachers were nuns although Eric was  also became a boarder at another Preparatory school, St Cyprian’s in  Eastbourne. He was able to gain scholarships to Wellington and hen when a place became available at Eton the most famous of British private schools where as although the John Fisher wanted to be recognised as a Public School, employing an international Olympic Athletics Coach, it never made it. In both instances we were dependent on having additional support for the required fees.

It was our respective years 18 to 21 which were so different in outward appearance yet we both gained experiences which were to govern the rest of our lives and make us individualist, slightly anarchistic socialists. As he approached his eighteenth year and University was considered the normal; next step he was  unable to gained the scholarship and fees to attend a top class college considered the norm for Eton students and joining the Indian Police service, in Borneo because his mother’s family resided there and his father had returned to England and retirement. Eton was then an establishment geared up to providing young men to help rule the empire so his appointment was a natural progression.

In my instance I had panicked on first discovering my problem which short term memory learning so that despite hours of home work and continuous reading during he holiday  I could not remember stuff when it came to examinations and given the mock general certificate of education results had opted out of Latin essential then for Oxbridge and then  decided to seek employment  without going into the sixth form and gained work in the Finance Department of Middlesex and then Croydon Councils before failing as Olivetti sales representatives and becoming Down and Out and becoming a leading activist in the non violent direct action movement against weapons of mass destruction and an executive committee member of the local Labour party and choosing to go to prison for six months  rather than agree to stop my activities. Eric went to Burma and his account of the experience was broadcast by the BBC as part of its celebration of his work.

The first of the biographical programmes was Burmese Days and which I presumed was based on an autobiographical work. It begins with his disappointment that the female friend from his childhood (Jacintha Buddicom) was not interested in marriage and going to Burma to become with wife of a Colonial Policeman.

Jacintha Laura May Buddicom (10 May 1901 – 1994) was a poet and a childhood friend of George Orwell (Eric Blair). They first met  in the summer of 1914 when he was standing on his head in a field at the bottom of their garden in Ship lake (Oxfordshire) south of Henley where the two families lived. One or both appear to have recorded that when she asked what he was doing he replied “You are "You are noticed more if you stand on your head than if you are the right way up." The radio programme makes references to this moment when it covers their experience of growing up writing and reading together, although the relationship included his younger sister and her younger brother and sister.

Her main complaint stated in the programme is that she still had the intention to go to Oxford which he had now abandoned, maintain and develop her intellectual interests and write. When he persists she ridicules the notion  going to Burma and playing eh role of a colonial wife to a policeman and attempts to force her to yield to him physically, something which she implies they willingly attempted before and it failed because they were more like brother and sister than potential lovers.

The programme also records, in a conversation Blair is said to have had  with a stranger on his way to the frontier out post of Katha after  an incident with an elephant which I will come  to shortly, that he continued to write to her after his arrival in Burma  but she did not reply because he says his letters were full of complaints about the life he had found for himself. The programme gives he impression that this was the end of their contact.

My understanding is that on his return from Burma and staying he visited the Buddicomes but Jacintha was not  there because she was away after having a child (1927) from a  relationship. She then had a relationship with an unnamed peer for 30 years and  one source claims that she did not realise that that her childhood friend was George Orwell until shortly before his death but they did corresponded, telephoned and planned to meet. She attended his funeral (unnoticed) in 1950.

She wrote a book about their childhood together Eric and us in which she challenges the portrait he has left of his experience during the same years. She left the copyright of her book and papers to a relative who in 2006 published an updated version of the book which included the information that the reason why she  had not replied to his letters was that he had attempted to rape her.

The main part of the BBC programme covers two situations  during his  years in Burma. He was called to act in a situation where an elephant had run amok and flattened  and killing a man  as well as destroying building. He was under great pressure to  shoot the animal from his white subordinate and his local police contact although he is reported as reluctant but agrees to do so when he told to do otherwise would involve a loss of face before the increasingly large crowd when the elephant is cornered and quietened down. He has to send for a larger gun and although the first shot stops and then drops the creature he has to fire several rounds from two weapons before the  animal dies after half an hour although before this the locals have begun to cut up the  creature for its meat. He expresses considerable regret noting that for decades the creature had served men and did not deserve to be treated in this way.   He is then summoned to see his chief to says a complain has been made by the firm who owned the elephant demands that action is taken against he officer and this the reason for his being sent to the backwoods, effectively ending  his career.

It is on his way to the posting that he meets a philosophical teacher of the  locals. They meet when Eric enters the compartment after having a physical confrontation with some local young men who are angry with the continuing presence of white colonials in their country, he loses his temper and beats the most vociferous. He expresses shame at having behaved in this way although as he a admits he has beaten native prisoners as part of his official duties.

He explains his dislike for the country and his role and that his life blood is reading novels which are sent out, His reading distinguishes himself from his colleagues who read for entertainment and passing the time while his is more discerning and critical. The companion is clearly a communist who sympathises with Blair’s apparent distrust of the locals but which the Scotsman from Aberdeen pointedly explains the consequential reaction to colonialism and the exploitation of the mineral and occupational wealth of the country for the City of London. This is something which his boss had also explained was the purpose of their presence to protect the commercial interests of the empire. The teacher was employed in native education and expressed surprise that the people appeared to accept  their exploitation for the profits of a few without rising up. He explains that his father had a job with the port authority which required him to ask the masters their  port of destination and this has fuelled his desire to visit the places for himself.

Blair puts the blame for his presence on his father and the rejection of his suit by Cynthia who cried when he when he went shooting but did not respond to his advances. He said he did not understand women. The stranger suggests he will have made do with a native woman, who cooks and cleans and does not answer back. Blair reacts to this accusation, but in the programme he also does not deny. Blair sounds self piteous and questions the purpose of existence, cogs in the wheels of evolution. The stranger challenges this concept and tells him to go outside his experience of education and society of his peers and find out how the rest of world live and tells him to read the 11th Theses ( of Karl Marx) although they part without stranger explaining what it is in anyway.

The programme then includes experiences from being Down and Out in London and the  in Spanish Civil War, Homage to Catalonia and where he asks a Communist does he know what is the 11th theses and who explains this where Marx argued against the Philosopher Feuerbach. This was written in 1845 but not published until 1924  the main point the 11th in this short work is his conclusion that philosophers attempt to describe the world as it from different perspective  but not to change it  The stranger was telling Orwell he needed to act and not just think and  talk about it. Orwell was already conscious of this because previously he talks of the need to feel and be in reality to feel alive rather than existing. I also felt like that then and  look at trouble it got be into! And for Orwell he needed to take a very different pathway (Theses on Feuerbach by Karl Marx Google it)

My understanding is that Blair was trained at Mandalay in 1922 after travelling via the Suez canal and that after a period at the principal hill station was posted to the frontier outpost in 1924. He was responsible for the security of two hundred thousand people and from there he became an Assistant Division Inspector to a town  with an oil refinery close to Rangoon. In 1925 he moved again to a town with the second largest prison and then in 1926 to where his maternal grandmother lived and it was towards the end of that year he was assigned to Katha the location of his first novel Burmese Days. In 1927 he developed a fever and because he was entitled to leave in England (after five years) and returned to his family to recover  and while on holiday with them decided to change his life and resigned  from the police. It was while on in France swimming naked the pool villa while the rest of the family were out and I spent the day eating crusty French bread, olives and salami drinking wine looking down the valley in 1991 that I reappraised my life and determined to write the novel that  had fermented inside me for the previous thirty years. It was written in 1994 and I keep rewriting the opening chapter from year  to year or two. It is set

The  novel Burmese Days was not published until 1934 and  according to once source it is a portrait of Imperial Britain although Orwell attempts to present a wide  perspective from the naked exploitation and commercialism to the provision of health and education, and order and security. The widespread racism of predominantly white Britain is reflected not surprising given the country that produced the biggest slavers in the Caribbean and the USA and the superiority of the white races over others but also those who rejected such prejudices or were indifferent to the issue. The others issue was identity and its collapse of the basis on which the central character had built his life. It is not  a book preaching revolution or major change, or promoting  socialist or communist ideas. I have not placed the book on my reading list. I still do not know why he  commenced to break in such a fundamental way from the belief system created for him by his family, education and social structure and which would lead him to abandon his attractive young wife to kill fascists.

Saturday, 2 February 2013

Down and out in Paris

I was delighted to come across a BBC radio production of George Orwell’s Animal Farm last week and quickly discovered that the programme is part of a new series The Real Gorge Orwell. He was Eric Blair in fact and I will write more later about him, his wife who came from South Shields, Animal Farm, Homage to Catalonia, part one which is being repeated today with the second part on Sunday afternoon, a discussion of his short story Politics and Language and Burma, a biographical play. 1984 is to close the season plus other programmes and I have found a site where all his works are available to read.

It is fitting that the BBC has chosen Down and Out in Paris and London as  his work to abridge in ten episodes for the book at bedtime this week and next, given that more people have become down and out or become greater strugglers wage slaves in the UK during the past two years because of the policy of the coalition just as the situation in the UK and the USA in the 1920’s when on his return from a colonial policeman in Burma he decided to explore life on the streets and the poverty of being a wage slave to survive first in London and then in Paris while reporting as a journalist and wanting to become a professional writer.

In the Guardian on Thursday 24th January 2012, the new George Orwell day, Stewart Jeffries asks what would Orwell make of the state affairs in 2013? What  would he be writing about and on what would his reputation be founded? His article disappoints although I agree  with the conclusion that he would certainly have written a 1984 to which I would have added Animal Farm given his views the Russians and the Germans through Communism and  Fascism created totalitarian societies and how much greater knowledge of this reality of political speak he would have gained had he lived after 1950 when he died at the age of 46.

 Anthony Powell The right wing writer whose books I possess and admire ( and want to reread again) argued in his journals that he anticipated that Orwell as he aged would have become right wing, anti CND, in favour of the Falklands War, and against the miners strikes to which I must say perhaps in terms of the specifics,  because his  writings always suggested the individualist, the liberal democratic socialist at heart, and a man who liked  good order but hated injustice and waste. Whether he would have earned a living writing about food, another suggestion, is more  questionable although he would  have campaign about food waste and its misrepresentation  for commercial reasons. Would he approve of reality TV programmes? For this piece I will review the first week of  Being down ( but I suggest not out) in Paris, listening to the radio broadcasts while I reread my copy of the book purchased three shillings and sixpence in in 1964 while I was the University of Birmingham, Penguin books edition  reprinted in 1963.

I was disappointed with the first abridgement on Monday evening January 29th 2013, because of the omission of the whole of the second chapter. In 1927 Orwell undertook the experience of being a tramp on the streets of London and experience which other journalists and social commentators have undergone since and then he went to Paris in 1928 to  have the same experience again and the book begins with surviving on six francs a day in a bug ridden lodging house.  In fairness to the BBC the second chapter is not essential to make the point  of what it is like to survive just on bread while seeing  the piles of food in shops, the food left on plates in  restaurants or dumped in trash cans.  However part of the purpose of his writing is not just to describe his experience but report on the condition and behaviour of others and in this respect the tale of Charlie is relevant and could have been summarised in a few words saying Charlie boasted of how he stole 1000 francs from his brother and the blew the lot on raping a girl kept as a slave by an old hag in a cellar.

The episode highlights one aspect of being poor without expectation of a permanent change in circumstances, the tendency to blow what ever comes ones way without regard to  tomorrow, in this instance 1000 francs on a brief sexual encounter and while Orwell is surviving on six. It is the poor who tend to gamble and smoke more on a regular basis often at the expense of food, shelter and new clothes; and thirdly that sexual slavery is nothing new. The omission smacks of censorship although it may be typical of the Book at Bedtime abridgements although I also mention in the context that the original Animal Farm film now available as a U certificate was graded X for over 18 year olds only when first released to theatres.

It is an abridgement series but in this instance missing out on some fo the characters not only reduces the colour of the piece but also reveals that it is no accident why many of  the characters are poor,  the inadequate, or immoral beings, prone to prone to petty criminality and in some instance violence and therefore should be no surprise that they are where they are. What percentage  continues to be a matter for debate, a significant minority from my experience but something which does not affect any analysis and sense of injustice at the extremes between the poor and the wealthy.

The edited radio programme does communicate the reality of being down and out with the author ending the third chapter explaining the consolation in poverty, that is the feeling of relief, almost of pleasure that at last you have reached the lowest you can get of being genuinely down and out.” You have talked  so often of going to the dogs- and well, here are the dogs, and you have reached them, and you can stand it. It takes off a lot of anxiety.”

The second radio abbreviation covered the next four chapters to almost the end of seven(page 39) and  concerned his relationship with a Russian waiter called Boris who worked at a hotel and boasted of earning  100 francs a day in tips and hoped to save up for his own restaurant, something which all waiters dreamed of doing. Boris said he could get Blair, for Eric Blair is the actual birth name of the writer, a job if he wanted one. Then as the teaching English job ended and he was down to his last francs he went in search of the Russian, Boris, only to find that the man was in a worse position than himself living in a flea and bug invested slum, the room of someone who owed him  money, and where he had been sleeping rough under bridges have lost his job after an accident and breaking his back and still recovering he  was described as lame. He had hopes however about a Russian Restaurant that is opening  the following week but when they visit it is still being  created.

We learn a lot about Boris during  the  four chapters, of a wealthy family shot in the revolution and himself a Riffleman, a  Captain, his father had been a Colonel.  He had been with many women, to whom he writes to appeal for funds none of whom reply except who owed him  money but the letter was an excuse for giving nothing to him. He also had a love of chess as many Russians do,  and he was prejudiced against Jews, something which the BBC abridged out and which in fairness many Russians had at the time and still do.

We  also learn about  the pawn broking system in which you take in goods and receive a number and when the clerk has assessed he will call your number and make you an offer so that all  waiting will hear how  little or  how you   will get, and indeed if you are not offered anything. If you contest the offer, it may be withdrawn or you are offered less but if you go after lunch when the clerks have  eaten you are likely to get a better offer than in the morning when they have not.
It is also evident that if you want a job as a waiter you have to know the right person to bribe and Orwell describes how they bought a drink at the right place and waited for the permitted two hours without being introduced to someone calling for an employee because they had not realised  it was necessary to give the barman 20 francs. Their problem was that the Russian now with a limp was almost unemployable and of course Orwell had no experience and would  only get a job washing up in a kitchen for example on the say so of the Russian who had the experience. He manages to survive for one month when he receives 200 francs for some published work and then expecting only 5 or 10 francs for their winter coast they are given seventy from the pawn broker, probably a mistake, but they then  buy lots of food and drink, forge themselves and get drunk which seems to me the standards for those in this predicament.

The next part of the book better covered in the third abridgement describes what it is like working in a  hotel kitchen as a general dogsbody a plongeur. Boris gets a job as a waiter and smuggles out food over the first three days fo his employment until he gets Orwell the job. Before then in  the book there is the story of the Russian Duke who eat at the hotels and restaurants where he knew Russian officers were working as waiters and then borrowed 300 francs to pay for the food and  to survive which he never paid back or was expected as he was a Duke.

They then fall to a confidence trickster who pretends to run  a communist underground group above a laundry and demands 20 francs from the two as a sign of good faith promising Orwell 150 for articles about British politics and the life under the capitalist system. He promises to send a formal request within a couple fo day after they pay five francs of their remaining money and after a week when they go back there is no trace of the man who disappeared owing rent. However this is nothing like the new Tory led coalition approval for TV advising for loans to the poor at interest rates of over  1000% a year. The bastards including one firm  part of sponsoring Newcastle United.

Orwell is taken on because he speaks English and can help staff as most of the guests are Americans,  with his job to keep clean and ready the private restaurant for senior staff. He is offered a months work, the usual practice but at first says no because of the commitment to work in the new restaurant of the Russian which is due to open in two weeks and where they have both been offered better paid jobs. However when he tells Boris what he has done he is sent immediately back to accept the offer. If the new job comes and is better paid they can leave as there will be no shortage of others waiting to take their places. The way is to ask to be paid on a daily basis although one has to keep money on your person as anything left in outer clothing is stolen and everyone is on the fiddle regarding the food and the drink

He works at one of the top hotels in Paris and his description of how the hotel is run provides an important insight into what was the situation and may well continue to be in  most parts of the world  including some  of the greatest cities where tourist flock and where Orwell questions the value to humanity of their existence. The guests paid extraordinary prices then as now but then were cheated at every opportunity bringing to mind the Innkeeper in Les Misérables but then of course they usually have the funds to so indulge as was brought out  in the BBC TV series on one famous London Hotel series.

There is also a class as well as wages system among the 100 odd employees hired to serve the 200 odd customers. The top hotel employees have their own dining room the Maitre d’ Hotel has his own table with silver service and staff attending. The cooks have moustaches  to show their superiority over the waiters who earn more through tips than those on fixed wages, while the waiters insist on junior staff also being clean shaven as a show of their power. He paints in some colour observing that the older char women with still painted faces are usually former prostitutes. Everyone steals food and from each other with the cellar man selling the rest of the measures  set aside for a few sous if he trusts you.

However he has little sympathy for the guests who eat food with ingredients used in such a way to bring profit, drinks of short measure,  bed linen not properly laundered because of the turn arounds. The emphasis is on the appearance and the presentation, the smiles of service without sincerity or care.

Understandably  Orwell concentrates on the role and life of plongeur or dish washer. They work in filthy condition with no regard for cleanliness as waiters clean the sweat from their faces using the disgusting washing up water from the soiled utensils. The description reminds of the Arnold Wesker literal kitchen sink drama The Kitchen which I saw in theatre, listened to the radio play and have the text part of trio of his works.

He describes the going to work and the coming home at night among the other works, the fights and the swearing, except on Saturday night when they congregate as a small  bistro near the hotel  when the work is done around 11 pm and get drunk returning to their beds between one and two and to sleep through before the cycle begins again. Every Saturday a communist believer by day gets drunk and rises to make a speech, word for word the same, too drunk to notes that he is regarded as a comic turn along with those who dance or sing. He also praises the importance of sleep, describing awakened by a murder  by three men seen running off by hitting a man dead with a lead pipe that after the street checked that the man was dead and nothing could be done for him, they left him there and  immediately back to bed and too sleep,

Whereas the waiters and other senior staff could with some optimism plan to better themselves and to marry, the plongeur had no prospects given the hours of working sixty to one hundred every week there was no time to study to importance job prospects and there was only  sufficient money to get drunk once a week. But you had three meals a day, the rent was paid and here was pride in doing the job although he questions the necessity for the role and why it was done rather than people revolt and demand a better life. He argues that the rich even if they care do not involved themselves with the lives of the poor,  Cameron is presently accused of not having visited one of the soup kitchens that have arisen because of the ongoing levels of unemployment and lowering of wages and benefits in real terms.

Orwell argues that if you put the poor in good clothes under a good roof and they are no different from the rich and vice versa. This is only a partial  truth as it is important to separate those who have become addicted to a substance or have emotional  or psychological problems, or become recidivists from those unable because of disability or lack of jobs or because of the nature of work and its pay.

Thus Orwell has described his experience having nothing and  then as a wage slave. However his experience in Paris continues when influenced by Boris they make the mistake of leaving the hotel when called by the Russian restaurant owner that he is ready to open, but this is for next week.



Monday, 5 November 2012

Free Thinking at the Sage

Saturday November 3rd 2012 will not be remembered as the day itself but because of events that occurred, a BBC radio broadcast at the Sage Gateshead, a Newcastle Walkabout in warm afternoon sunshine and the most engaging of the Montalbano episodes throughout the two series this year.



The day commenced with uncertainty about what I should take with me and how long I would remain out. I had debated baking a baguette for salami and olives for lunches as I had only a few minutes between two planned events at midday. I decided against taking a bag with me although did put a small umbrella in my coat together with the ticket information and a notebook. I also failed to provide myself with as much time as appropriate after deciding on a little Wii exercise of some 15 minutes as it felt cold and indeed I had to zip up the double layered black Winter’s coat. I must make sure I have a woolly hat to hand.



It was just before 10.30 when I arrived at the Gateshead Metro Interchange station and I lost several minutes trying to find out the bus and stand for the Sage missing one and with close to 20 minutes for the next bus, twice the advertised every ten minutes painted on the side of some of the buses I decided to walk, a good decision. I went passed the new shopping development being created on the Get Carter Car park site and then the old Town Hall building which was used for the Tyneside Film Theatre while that was we being extended and refurbished, and then across a succession of pedestrian crossings to get to the entrance of the concert halls.



Since my last visit to the Sage there has been a major change with the ending of the splendid music listening library and Internet centre provided by Gateshead Leisure. This is now a second cafeteria restaurant. There has also been a major switching around with the ticket office outside Hall 2 and a shop outside Hall one. The cafeteria and the Brassiere are where they were. I had time for a coffee at £1.50 after collecting my tickets from the special BBC Free Thinking weekend desk. There was a separate bookstall related to the weekend speakers as well as a couple of screens showing one of the events already in progress. I had started the journey frustrated because I had brought a notebook but left a pen and was horrified at being asked to £2 for a Sage product, later when I purchased a pack of six pens for 99 pence at Rymans I found I had left the notebook at the Sage and ended up writing the notes on the way home on the back of the leaflet info about the event I had experienced.



The first recording of the morning was by Charlotte Blease a new Generation thinker providing a fifteen minute talk about the real nature of General Practice and medical diagnosis in general. She identified that there were a number of problems including those symptoms identified could match more than one problem and that the diagnostician was dependent to a great extent on what the patient was able to explain. My own experience is that without keeping records it is often difficult to remember when a change was noted or that a change occurs in such a way to suggest it needs to be reported or is considered part of the aging process or other natural imbalances which occur from time to time.



The talk was not an attack on medical practice being made but an attempt to place medical diagnosis in perspective. A current example is that even with a proven screening technique such as for breast cancer which is estimated to save 3000 to 4000 lives a year, for every one individual prescribed treatment a number were found not to have required it because what was detected did not lead to a malignant tumour yet without early detection women died unnecessarily.



There was no time for a comfort break between this talk and the first two major events with a panel approach to Rewriting History which was undertaken recently by Andrew Marr with his series on the history of human kind and which he reminded was part of a legacy with Bronowski The Ascent of Man. James Burke’s Connection and a series on Civilization which concentrated on the European cultures in the days of early Television. Anthony Beever is a leading military Historian who is completing or has completed a history of World War II from the World perspective which could argue that the World War commenced prior to 1939 with the Japanese attack and colonization of China. One memorable point made was that for 200 years Japan closed its borders and concentrated on it own development in terms of feeding its people and political and social government playing no part in the rest of the world, trading, politics, economics and this strengthened and led to self sufficiency. The third speaker Maria Misra was a Modern Historian whose primary subject was India while the chair for the session Rana Mitter background was Chinese History. What struck and a point briefly made later in the discussion is that the study of human kind is not the same as the study of the earth planet and that environmental changes, a la Hurricane superstorm Sandy can have more devastating consequences than the great wars, earthquakes, famines and floods etc against national and civil wars.



My point and one not made in the discussion is that given the potential mismatch between resources and population growth it can be argue that major disasters and wars are a way of stopping the population becoming too great for the planet‘s resources to sustain and that war also has proved to be a period of innovation and the rebuilding also becomes a time for economic growth as happened post second world war in Japan and Germany in particular.



Marr said that his work was leading up to the choice facing mankind was blowing themselves up or destroying the planet environmentally, or working towards the conquest of space and the unlimited possibilities and opportunities of that but also the threats given that the overwhelming populations of the Americas was destroyed by the importing of old world illnesses rather than through aggressive conquest. He said he was optimistic. I am not remembering the Ice Age and what happened to the indigenous Americans and is happening to the Africans.



I had to leave the discussion briefly when I knew I was going to have coughing fit so went out of some bottled water at an outrageous £1.60. Does anyone learn from History? Is there anything to learn? Karl Marx attempted to predict from selected historical events and circumstances while Hitler was enamoured by the ability of the British go control their empire was so few troops.



There was only 20 minutes before needing to queue for a good seat for the second discussion on Is Social Mobility overrated? There as time for a comfort visit and some sea salt and black pepper crisps 90p bring the total expenditure for the three events only £6.25 (I bought a ham and Cheese baguette from the Quayside Greggs on my walkabout),



The panel this time included the Guardian Polly Toynbee whose background includes the creator of Toynbee Hall in the East end of London always left of centre and currently President of the British Humanist Society and Treasurer of the Fabian Society. Lawrence Goldman is an Oxford Historian. The two other speakers were an obnoxious management consultant originally from New Zealand and a rational and practical woman from the North East who represented all types of schools in the region.



This was the least successful of the three events I attended. The problem was the vastly different perspectives, personalities and lifestyles on the panel looking at the problem from both of the telescope. On one hand the management consultant appeared to believe that individuals should be left to cope with their nature and nurture without state intervention and everything should be privatised and that it was in the natural order of things to be poor and the rich and for some people to move or down according to the decisions taken and the time and circumstances of their lives, while Toynbee appeared to believe that everyone should be able to achieve the best from their innate and acquired activities and the state should intervene to ensure an equality of opportunity.



I thought a better construction to the programme would have been to consider the extent which we are a class ridden society and its consequences or an examination of the obstacles to providing an equality of opportunity. The basic of living will always be food, warmth and shelter with work part of it and income associated with work a major factor. Education is good in itself but is usually associated with furthering opportunity while the arts and culture are and expression of what people feel about their lives and their society. Do I really want to encourage people to make more money that they need and then misuse their power or become aggressive and violent and social mobility is usually associated with people getting power and wealth to do what they want without regard to their obligations and duties to each other their families neighbourhood and communities.



The discussion on the day appeared to fix on Education while the current big issue is employment where capitalism and international capitalism are the governing factors together with the problem of allowing hordes in from European countries to come and work the jobs on low pay, mainly service and also other manual this creating an inter generational underclass. The third is shelter was not touched in the discussion.